WS Christmas Mafia 2022

[Chris]

Yea, when I asked I pretty much knew I was gonna get a pile of shit, but I figured I’d kick the tires. I’m leaving my duel vote for Ekko to win since I never got a coherent answer from Juice about why I shouldn’t.

Can't even blame you at this point, she's done nothing to help her cause. I'd say learn from it if I'm right and she flips town for next time but you never really do for these kinds of plays lol

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Vote Ekko Duel Winner

Vote Lynch Smark

-
Juice is probably town. I think Ekko is probably town. I value Ekko more even if I think Juice is more likely town between the two.

Smark, Barry, or Poyser would be my vote POE today. Smark already has a wagon going and is the has made me pause the least times after my initial scum lean read to say “wait maybe this is townie”.

Barry was probably neck and neck with Smark but then his attitude kind of struck me as townie when he bit back at Ekko but he did it a few more times after others acted like it was townie which could have been performative.

Poyser was pinging me with incoherence and looked like he was struggling at one point but I liked the way he bit at Ace for something and I liked his point that some of the reactions to Juice’s duel being so bad could have been performative (I think it was bad too but that seems like a townie thing to think about). I’ve only done one read of the thread. May check back to see who all reacted to that like that and if any seemed fake. Also some people were saying that incoherence (this is maybe too strong a word and I don’t mean it as an insult) is normal for him.

Chris is probably my strongest town read. I liked that he went from scum reading Ekko to getting paranoid about all the people town reading Ekko for something he wasn’t seeing. That’s a townie train of thought imo. I disagree with him on Ekko bc I’ve seen many shades of Ekko, but I understand someone who’s not seen as many shades. If one of Ekko or Chris is Town though I pick Chris

Tommy also probably town too based on pooling what others have said about him plus the way he’s over here trying to see if there’s anything to the Ace/Ekko thing to look at Ace while everyone else is preoccupied. Also considering he’s being widely town read he doesn’t really need to be digging under his own rocks as scum rn. Seems like unnecessary work.

Ekko has striken me as townie far more than not but I respect his scum game enough to know he’s not completely left the realm of what he’s capable of. I like that despite saying he’s burned and preemptively making himself an excuse he’s still top poster. I know myself as town I sometimes say that but then can’t help myself if I find myself in a situation like he’s in (which is a decent situation to be solving from) that I can’t help but be active. If I’m scum and I make an excuse like that I’m less likely to do so bc it’s easy to just stick with that energy. Idk if that part applies to Ekko bc I haven’t seen Town/Scum Ekko do it or if I have I didn’t make note of it, but that’s just how I am lol. And could see it applying to him too.

 

[CakeWalker]

Yea, when I asked I pretty much knew I was gonna get a pile of shit, but I figured I’d kick the tires. I’m leaving my duel vote for Ekko to win since I never got a coherent answer from Juice about why I shouldn’t.

i mean you dont really have a legit reason for Ekko to win the duel either - so this is good filler, but no content. Respect the attempt at a town tell though - pretty fake though

 

[CakeWalker]

Seeing I've had you pencilled and stated as 2nd mafia for ages

 

[Sister Abigail]

smark prolly scum
iffy on posyer
john indie-ish
grim was looking scummy early game but a bit better now

iso those for now and let me know what u see

What is Smark's username this game?

Not going to ISO Poyser. I struggle with his game and I don't feel like tackling that many posts just for a pre-read iso.

I think Grim had some defensive moments to start the game, but I think he's articulating his thoughts to show transparency. When I got him as scum before he subbed out last game I was here, he was more reserved and I didn't know how to create content.

I gave a quick iso of Jonn. I want to ask first why you're getting indie vibes?

 

[Kross Rhodes]

I’ve never been that strong of a day 1 player, but I like Ekko, Barry, Chris (I don’t think we scum you’d change your mind on the duel as much).

Not as keen on Juice, Ace, Poyser (not a strong feeling, but he seems a bit subdued thus far).

TP has also not provided much of anything. He wowed my request for his day 0 reads and didn’t come back.

I also think CP is being sketch. Not only for trying to wind Juice up without solving the game state, but a CP this uninvolved usually leads me to a scum CP.

 

[Kross Rhodes]

Vote Ekko Duel Winner

Vote Lynch Smark

-
Juice is probably town. I think Ekko is probably town. I value Ekko more even if I think Juice is more likely town between the two.

Smark, Barry, or Poyser would be my vote POE today. Smark already has a wagon going and is the has made me pause the least times after my initial scum lean read to say “wait maybe this is townie”.

Barry was probably neck and neck with Smark but then his attitude kind of struck me as townie when he bit back at Ekko but he did it a few more times after others acted like it was townie which could have been performative.

Poyser was pinging me with incoherence and looked like he was struggling at one point but I liked the way he bit at Ace for something and I liked his point that some of the reactions to Juice’s duel being so bad could have been performative (I think it was bad too but that seems like a townie thing to think about). I’ve only done one read of the thread. May check back to see who all reacted to that like that and if any seemed fake. Also some people were saying that incoherence (this is maybe too strong a word and I don’t mean it as an insult) is normal for him.

Chris is probably my strongest town read. I liked that he went from scum reading Ekko to getting paranoid about all the people town reading Ekko for something he wasn’t seeing. That’s a townie train of thought imo. I disagree with him on Ekko bc I’ve seen many shades of Ekko, but I understand someone who’s not seen as many shades. If one of Ekko or Chris is Town though I pick Chris

Tommy also probably town too based on pooling what others have said about him plus the way he’s over here trying to see if there’s anything to the Ace/Ekko thing to look at Ace while everyone else is preoccupied. Also considering he’s being widely town read he doesn’t really need to be digging under his own rocks as scum rn. Seems like unnecessary work.

Ekko has striken me as townie far more than not but I respect his scum game enough to know he’s not completely left the realm of what he’s capable of. I like that despite saying he’s burned and preemptively making himself an excuse he’s still top poster. I know myself as town I sometimes say that but then can’t help myself if I find myself in a situation like he’s in (which is a decent situation to be solving from) that I can’t help but be active. If I’m scum and I make an excuse like that I’m less likely to do so bc it’s easy to just stick with that energy. Idk if that part applies to Ekko bc I haven’t seen Town/Scum Ekko do it or if I have I didn’t make note of it, but that’s just how I am lol. And could see it applying to him too.

New player?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

New player?

I played last years Christmas game here. And I’ve played with a few of you from here on WG (Candy is Lethal I think I saw? And I played with Wang once there too but he was totally inactive.

 

[CakeWalker]

Vote Ekko Duel Winner

Vote Lynch Smark

-
Juice is probably town. I think Ekko is probably town. I value Ekko more even if I think Juice is more likely town between the two.

Smark, Barry, or Poyser would be my vote POE today. Smark already has a wagon going and is the has made me pause the least times after my initial scum lean read to say “wait maybe this is townie”.

Barry was probably neck and neck with Smark but then his attitude kind of struck me as townie when he bit back at Ekko but he did it a few more times after others acted like it was townie which could have been performative.

Poyser was pinging me with incoherence and looked like he was struggling at one point but I liked the way he bit at Ace for something and I liked his point that some of the reactions to Juice’s duel being so bad could have been performative (I think it was bad too but that seems like a townie thing to think about). I’ve only done one read of the thread. May check back to see who all reacted to that like that and if any seemed fake. Also some people were saying that incoherence (this is maybe too strong a word and I don’t mean it as an insult) is normal for him.

Chris is probably my strongest town read. I liked that he went from scum reading Ekko to getting paranoid about all the people town reading Ekko for something he wasn’t seeing. That’s a townie train of thought imo. I disagree with him on Ekko bc I’ve seen many shades of Ekko, but I understand someone who’s not seen as many shades. If one of Ekko or Chris is Town though I pick Chris

Tommy also probably town too based on pooling what others have said about him plus the way he’s over here trying to see if there’s anything to the Ace/Ekko thing to look at Ace while everyone else is preoccupied. Also considering he’s being widely town read he doesn’t really need to be digging under his own rocks as scum rn. Seems like unnecessary work.

Ekko has striken me as townie far more than not but I respect his scum game enough to know he’s not completely left the realm of what he’s capable of. I like that despite saying he’s burned and preemptively making himself an excuse he’s still top poster. I know myself as town I sometimes say that but then can’t help myself if I find myself in a situation like he’s in (which is a decent situation to be solving from) that I can’t help but be active. If I’m scum and I make an excuse like that I’m less likely to do so bc it’s easy to just stick with that energy. Idk if that part applies to Ekko bc I haven’t seen Town/Scum Ekko do it or if I have I didn’t make note of it, but that’s just how I am lol. And could see it applying to him too.

and I found the missingin active.

Ekko/Bedlam/McHenry/Abigail

 

[Sister Abigail]

New player?

That's the fucking legendary Doctor Prof. I'm actually shocked to see him here.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Who is @Sister Abigail on WG?

 

[Chris]

Player List:

Chris
Hayterade - FKA Switchblade
Juice McClane - FKA Lich King
Ekkologix
The Grimch - FKA some Grim variation, AKA Barry
Wangman Page
Sister Abigail
Candy Jade - FKA as Lethal Jade
Mandalorian
Poyser
John McClane - FKA McNightstalker
Tweet
Tommy Bedlam
Dr_Professor83
Ace Marvel
CraigPelton
T-Pein™
Shawn
PHEN0M

@Ace Marvel I think these are all the name changes for reference

@Sister Abigail

 

[Sister Abigail]

I played last years Christmas game here. And I’ve played with a few of you from here on WG (Candy is Lethal I think I saw? And I played with Wang once there too but he was totally inactive.

Well what a fucking surprise, grasshopper.

 

[Sister Abigail]

@Sister Abigail

Bless your soul.

 

[CakeWalker]

imagine actually admitting you town read someone less - but still want them to win a lynch battle. LMAO

thats some funny ass play pho sho