summary up to 647:
good
@Dr_Professor83 - unecessary convoluted role but town asfk gameplay. also made enemies with peter and mafia from day 1 and likely got roleteacked by barry in n3 so mafia knew his role yet never pushed his lynch meaning they know he is just town. i am looking at anyone trying to push this slot cuz thats opportunistic asfk
@Sky - lie detected by tweet yet never pushed by him meaning she scanned truth. unless the indie is immune to lie detects, which i doubt, sky is basically mechanically cleared by mafia not pushing her, similar to prof. if tweet got a non true result, he would of haaard pushed sky day 1 for town cred
@T-Pein™ - the pgo claim ensures none targets him. neither town nor mafia. that seems scummy asfk on paper and allows him to coast with miminal contributions which he did. BUT the guy is foken pushing the survivor. like this is some 5d chess sht if tpein is indie here since the indie wins with the survivor and jeff should be the last person tpein pushes. tbh jeff should be the last person anyone pushes actually, specially the 3rd indie. also his other scum read, chris up to page 647, got night killed and i doubt tpein would shoot someone he is going hard for their lynch, especially mid argument. it doesnt add up to me tbh. tpein is good for me.
maybe good
@Hans Gruber - we have no proof if he joined mafia or not but i think he didnt do so given the interactions with smark and barry and if he joined them then that makes the concensus a liar. its too many things going agaisnt him being bad. we jave no proof yes, but for him to be scum then another person (jobber) has to also be scum and liar about census. there is no world where jeff is scum and jobber isnt because census came after jeff got the offer to join mafia and rejected it. also for jeff to be scum then blain has to be scum as well else jeff wud wanna lynch him opportunistially instead of defend him. not to mention jeff wouldnt talk about what the coal does if he turned scum but he did come out with it all withour being pressured.
@Jobber Doink - i don't know where to start with doink. gameplay screams towny, but role screams indie. he seems to get abilities related to the dead roles one way or another like a grave robber. i love transparency but tbh jobber never actually scum hunted nor was mechanically cleared. the best thing going for him is messaging tpein n1, but even the message content itself was useless. perosnally krogo plays different as indie every time and open wolfs in a manner different to here. he tends to have fun around with killing roles and works with town. hes done it 3 times in the past atleast and hes done it here by killing smark. i seen him try constantly to put players in the PoE when he is scum. the defeatist attitude he displays here is different from his scum fighting back attitude. i will personally say hes good, but gna have to convince the others. if hes bad then ive been completely fooled. wellplayed
maybe bad
@blaze - hes the player i remember the least about in the game. he basically took both coal and milk and is fine rn. he is the player in the safest position as of right now to win as indie since he can survive 2 deaths i think. he never took a stance on his own this entire game. kept coasting and never bothered using his ability, which to be fair, we never asked for. honestly hes the least player i interacted with this game from the rest of the bunch and is the one spooking me the most rn if alco wasnet it. i need help reading this slot.
bad asfk
@Alco - this slot has absolutely 0 scum hunting, 0 proactive gameplay, 0 constructive contributions. blaine was coasting early game and just wanted to throw his claim out there with literally being asked once. like hes hinting something for mafia. maybe thought mafia knew what the coal does? hes also being super reactive this phase. only talks when being pushed or suspected but not otherwise which i take as a big scum indicative actions because its clear to me hes unable to create content at this stage. partly because he joined late but there is a limit to how much excuses i can give a rep. he had enough time to catch up but never made proper attemps to. and finally about his role, its literally the most useless sht for town. its straight up anti town to help convert a player to mafia. like i said if jeff never told us what coal does, we wouldnt even know.
like heck how the fk we know jeff didnt convert to mafia and alco is a bad indie rn and both dont wanna lynch each others?
i don't wanna start succumbing too deep into late game paranoia man but i really feel its this slot that we r looking for. game should end with this lynch. everyone just feels more townier than alco right now so i will trust my gut
