Who's the most unexpected wrestler you've ever watched live?

[Leon TrotSky]

Decided to bring this question to this site. My answer will always be Bull Dempsey. He's exactly the sort of guy you'd never expect to come over here. No name value and no love for the biz

 

[Chris]

Charlie Haas in 2021 comes to mind for me

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

fucking Effy Gibbes and James Ellsworth at the exact same show in 2016

 

[Skyefire]

Bryan Danielson after he was fired and rehired by WWE in 2010. It was his second-last indie commitment after his surprise return at Summerslam. He wrestled Jon Moxley about a mile from where I lived and still live in Cincinnati. He would wrestle Moxley again the next night in Indianapolis.

 

[Deadd2009]

The Headbangers in 2012 while they were feuding with the Briscoes of all tag teams in ROH. They were wearing masks and managed by Truth Martini.

 

[BSE]

My first wrestling event was a WWECW House Show in 2006

I was very proud to see Rob Van Dam, Sabu, Sandman and Tommy Dreamer. CM Punk wrestled on this show but I don’t remember it. I didn’t know who he was at the time.

The opener was Rodney Mack vs Balls Mahoney, the first match I ever saw in person. I was 7 years old so I loved it. I doubt anyone in the world has ever enjoyed a Balls Mahoney vs Rodney Mack match as much as I did that night.