Which Gimmicks Do You Wish Got Over Or Pushed?

[Y2Jayne]

I don't think as good but, mella personality fits it

I agree for the personality. But without trying to sound mean, Carmella looks like a reality Tv star (surgery, fake tan etc.) and I don't think that would work for that gimmick. Toni looks more natural.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I agree for the personality. But without trying to sound mean, Carmella looks like a reality Tv star (surgery, fake tan etc.) and I don't think that would work for that gimmick. Toni looks more natural.

Yea for sure

 

[Deadd2009]

Kevin Thorn. I know the Mordecai gimmick fizzled out but the same dude ended up doing the Thorn gimmick which lasted a lot longer than it should have. Would have been a great feud for Kane or Taker.

 

[Jay-Ashley]

Would American Badass Undertaker count?

 

[Deadd2009]

Are you asking if ABA Taker shoulda gotten over or with my idea.

 

[Jay-Ashley]

Are you asking if ABA Taker shoulda gotten over or with my idea.

ABA Taker should have gotten over. I agree with Mordecai/Kevin Thorn

 

[Deadd2009]

I mean you could say he was still over regardless of gimmick, especially during all of 2001.

 

[Jay-Ashley]

Fair, but it seems like the undead persona/satanic persona was always more over than him just being a badass biker that beats the shit out of people leaves on a harley

 

[#Waddles]

Sean O'Haire's Devil's advocate run in '03 fits the criteria.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Maven in general especially after Survivor series

Eugene (honestly at one point you could argue he was one of the biggest babyfaces on roster)

Regal 08 (self inflicted again but the king Regal stuff was good)

The Boogeyman (always felt like you could done some cool heel stuff with svr stuff aside)

 

[Jay-Ashley]

Bob "Spark Plug" Holly mainly because it combined two things rural people like. Wrestling and NASCAR

 

[BSE]

Kevin Thorn. I know the Mordecai gimmick fizzled out but the same dude ended up doing the Thorn gimmick which lasted a lot longer than it should have. Would have been a great feud for Kane or Taker.

It got Ariel on TV so it wasn't all bad.

 

[BSE]

"The Human Suplex Machine" Tazz never got a fair chance in WWE, although most of the ECW guys didn't.

 

[Jay-Ashley]

DDP in WWE as a whole

 

[Y2Jayne]

Sean O'Haire's Devil's advocate run in '03 fits the criteria.

Hey, you're not telling us anything we don't already know.