What is your opinion on Kurt Angle?

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


What is your opinion on Kurt Angle?

  • I enjoy him. Still a great performer.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I don't really care for him anymore.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
  • Poll closed .

Hometown Kid

Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
955
Reaction score
1
Points
18
Age
32
Location
Columbia, Tennessee
Kurt is often a machine in his matches, he works his formula to perfection, and even though he goes to comfort spots often (not all the time like some claim), he's got a lot of room to work with because technically he's stronger than anyone on the planet. He innovated himself many times over the years character-wise, and I think he's pulled it off a lot better than Jericho has with his characters, and Y2J is well respected in that regard. A lot of people say he's this generation's Bret, but I actually find Kurt to be a mixture of Bret and Owen, along with his amateur background. I rate him as high as anybody, and although I don't think he's the greatest wrestler of all time, I wouldn't argue with him being awarded that title. Even currently, he just pulled off the match of the year so far last night. A month or two off can hopefully get him rested and healed, as that's the only concern that's glaringly a problem.

Whoever thinks he's trash is just trying too hard to sound smart, and is over-analyzing things.
 

xtremebadass

Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2006
Messages
916
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Chicago, IL
^^^^How can you and se76 say you do not care for him anymore? I just refuse to believe you both said that. I just do not get it.

It is really hard to explain LKP, but I blame TNA for it. He was great in the first couple years he was in TNA, but suddenly he just became really stale to me. His matches are still top notch, but it just seems repetitive like I have seen it before no matter what he does in TNA. :(

Plus I heard he is leaving for awhile right?
 

MizMasta3000

Active Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
Messages
2,520
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
30
He has really done all there is to do in TNA. Been world champ a few times. Had a dominating stable. Top notch feuds with the best (Sting, AJ, JJ, Joe, etc.)
 

LKP

Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
259
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Age
41
Location
Uk
I still think although his tank is almost empty, he can offer us more awesome matches and moments. Im not bored or think he is stale. In fact Jeff Jarrett, abyss and hhh are people i do not care for. Kurt Angle is up there with the people i love seeing on tv every week.
 

Axis

Active Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
1,149
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
35
He was probably the best wrestler in the world from 2001 (though some of his face stuff during the Invasion was hokey) to 2003. He was really great since then, but over the past few years he's undoubtedly lost his "best in the world" status. He's still very, very good, but I definitely respect the argument that his matches are fairly formulaic and that he relies a lot on spots. One of my biggest faults with him is that he's largely responsible for the ending of doing a few finisher reversals, then a few finisher kickouts, then the finisher. It was really awesome when he did it a lot in 2004-2005, but since then it's just become mundane. He's dug himself into a position where his false finishes just don't mean much anymore, and it's difficult to get hooked into his matches.

People love to jerk off to a lot of his TNA work, but honestly the only really fucking awesome match that I can recall that he's had in the past few years is versus Styles in their Last Man Standing match. His stuff with Joe was pretty awesome, but sort of a let down, though due mostly to atrocious booking. I haven't seen his match this Sunday against Anderson, though I've heard good things from people that don't consistently praise Angle matches solely because they have Angle. These examples show that Angle can certainly pull out a fucking awesome match, and he's always reliable to deliver a solid match, but he's definitely no longer the Kurt Angle that would undoubtedly put on a 3.5+ star match if given 7+ minutes.

So, still entertaining and very good, but definitely no longer the best in the world. I would probably be willing to put him on a list of best 10 - 15 of all time though.
 

straight_edge76

Active Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2007
Messages
1,679
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
34
Location
Yakima, Washington
^^^^How can you and se76 say you do not care for him anymore? I just refuse to believe you both said that. I just do not get it.

Like XBA said, I just lost interest in him that's all. I am not shitting on his in ring ability, the man can go point blank. I have never been a Kurt Angle FAN per say but I have admired what he was able to do in the ring with so many different types of opponents. Dude can also flat out talk, there are very few guys who can be just as good, if not a better face then a heel. He plays both wonderfully (personally I prefer the early "Three I's" Kurt to anything else, but that's just me). When he first came to TNA I had extremely high hopes for him. His feud with Samoa Joe was awesome from a match standpoint but the booking of the feud had me scratching my head at times tbh. He had almost consistant 4+ star matches with him. His matches with AJ were also pretty damn good. The Last Man standing match that they had could arguably be one of, if not his his best match in TNA.

He needs an extended break, no doubt. If anyone deserves a long, summer long break it is him I think that a break up until BFG would really do quite a bit in not only helping his body rest from all of the nagging injuries but also potentially freshen up his character imo. For the majority of his time in TNA he has been going non stop.
 

MizMasta3000

Active Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
Messages
2,520
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
30
I was a Kurt Angle fan ever since he blew his nose in Tiger Ali Singh's flag.
 

PeepShow

Best in the World
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
18,282
Reaction score
338
Points
83
Age
34
Favorite Wrestler
oAYiXZo
Favorite Wrestler
eAVr0ua
Favorite Wrestler
w7tcn6p
Favorite Wrestler
FOxu9qI
Favorite Wrestler
nock3cf
Favorite Wrestler
tLCb5kv
Favorite Sports Team
66EZrsh
Favorite Sports Team
OPg6il8
Favorite Sports Team
T5Zw0Si
More votes plz
 
Joined
Apr 18, 2010
Messages
169
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Age
49
I've always had respect for Angle's talent in the ring even if I don't list him as one of my favorites. As a talker, he's always run the thin line between decent and awful, but I'm okay with that as long as he makes up for it in the ring, which he does.

On that note, the guy needs to take a few months off to rest up and get over these mounting nagging injuries. At times, it seems like he's already burned himself out and is beyond running on fumes. To an extent, I agree with LKP - 6 months could do wonders to rejuvenate Kurt and would probably make his return to TNA a big event, if done right.
 

KenFan4life

Active Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2007
Messages
1,026
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
32
Location
Titletown, Mexico
Kurt Angle is on that list of guys that can consistently pull off "EPIC" matches....
The list of guys such as like....Ric Flair in his prime, Steamboat, HBK, probably someone like Triple H before he tore up his knees(2000-2001) or Stone Cold when he was all out brawler badass guy...idk, but basically "those" kinds of guys that can just pull out a motyc on nearly every ppv.
blah.
 
Joined
Mar 29, 2010
Messages
583
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Age
32
Location
Melbourne
God that 'poster' is so fucking totally BKB! I swear he's the only other one I've seen say that stuff about Kurt.

Only one on this forum, but that doesn't really surprise me a whole lot. Most people here are huge SPOTZ type of guys, and aside from you, I haven't seen anyone actually defend Angle with any real substance.

And nah, I'd never try to have an intelligent convo w/Lucas, cos you know it's just impossible. ;D

The guy is definitely one of the greatest professional wrestlers in the past decade no doubt about that.

But if you ask me as of right now, I really don't care for him anymore.

Kurt Angle came into TNA with such momentum, had a great angle with Samoa Joe, great matches with AJ Styles and Jeff Jarrett, and managed to win the IWGP and TNA titles to his resume. However, over the past 2 or so years in TNA, I really have lost interest in Angle. He was looking bad at one point. He got really skinny, real pale, started growing his hair back, looked like he was going insane, but then again he was dealing with alot of problems. He did that stint with the Main Event Mafia which was a total bomb. They could have been the greatest stable ever, but TNA messed that one up. Sometimes I watch TNA lately and it is almost like Kurt Angle doesn't exist. Who knew Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair's arrival could push Angle so far aside. His program with Anderson has been an intense and passionate one, but for me anyways, since Anderson was involved I just totally didn't pay attention. However, I did watch it for the most part and still Kurt's role in TNA has really shrunk. TNA really depleted my interest in Angle.

When Angle was in WWE though, he was flawless, definitely one of my favorites. His matches and feuds were insane.

He won the FAKE IWGP Title.

Whoever thinks he's trash is just trying too hard to sound smart, and is over-analyzing things.

lol'd

I assume this is directed towards the fact that he's very spot heavy, which he is. Throwing meaningless shit into a match is a big problem in TNA in general, and Angle only adds to that.


As shocking as it may sound, Axis probably comes closest to what I think on Angle. However, I still differ somewhat.

First of all, I think Angle can still put on the great matches, even in a short amount of time. I still think though, that he's going to have to be out there with a superior worker who is willing to guide him (ie 'Taker or even backstage agents, which don't appear to be doing shit in TNA) as to what he should be doing. The problem is that on his own, Angle relies far too heavily on spots for mine, and is also far too formulaic in the style that he depends on against almost everyone. He needs that guidance.

His matches with AJ Styles earlier this year sum up my thoughts pretty perfectly. AJ is a guy that relies on spots a bit too heavily too, and when mixed with Angle, what did we get? A logical match? Nope. Just a shitload of finishes and spots all thrown together for the sake of it. I've had this discussion w/Great One, but I'll throw it out here too, but I also hate the way in which he wrestled his matches with Wolfe by going out there and using a side headlock to show his hatred to kick the match off. You don't show your hatred by locking in a resthold. Awful.

Still, with all that said, Angle does what he knows works for the TNA crowd, who in general seem to enjoy spotfests, and bumps like a fucking trooper, which I can't help but feel he'll end up regretting majorly. Do I still think the guy can do something great like he did with Lesnar in 2003, or 'Taker in '03/'06? Sure. Do I think it could possibly happen in TNA, though? Nope.
 

Hometown Kid

Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
955
Reaction score
1
Points
18
Age
32
Location
Columbia, Tennessee
I don't know why "lol'd" comes in, if anything, there are too many people here who try to pound things unfairly while using "psychology" as the basis of their argument just to sound smart, when spots or not, is still great. The fact that he relies on spots is true, and I agree his best match before Anderson was against AJ LMS. But my real thing that I don't understand is, because he does a side headlock at the start of the match, ruins the other 15 minutes of it? Absolutely ridiculous, like I said, over analyzing things. The only real spotfest recently of his I recall were against AJ on. Jan. 4 and Supershow before BFG, which were just agregious. TBF he's not had a lot of chances of late, but I can't remember any matches with finisher-finisher-finisher to the point of driving it into the ground back to his MEM days besides AJ.

Now where James is coming from has merit, i'm not even disagreeing with the criticisms so saying he's overrated is one thing, but for someone to say he's OJ like trash, is insane.
 
Joined
Mar 29, 2010
Messages
583
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Age
32
Location
Melbourne
I don't think it's over analysing things. I think it's just stupid little small things like that that really make the whole leadup to the match pointless, because ultimately he's just going to do the same thing anyway. If you're paying for a Pay-Per-View to see the conclusion of a blood feud, you don't want to see headlocks. You want to see them knock each other the fuck out, and they should want to do it too. It's things like that that annoy me so much about Angle.

His match with AJ at Genesis was also very much a spotfest. I haven't seen the last few Pay-Per-Views, but I will try to watch Angle/Anderson, since I heard from a few people who I tend to agree with in general that it was a good match. Apparently Angle didn't have to sell a whole lot either, which helps.

I used to like OJ. :(
 
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
2,923
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
41
Location
Badstreet, USA
I won't vote because neither choice reflects how I feel. I still feel he is a top ten worker in the entire world, but because he is in the worst promotion I am somewhat apathetic to him, I won't define his merits or what he has done to endear himself to me, that's already been well stated. But what I will say is that he certainly needs to come home. TNA, like WCW with Bret Hart, has no idea how to use Angle. On the other hand the E has and can utilize him perfectly and his American hero character is almost tailor made for a PG product. Plus he and Taker would be the only people who could give the fans something to follow up this year's Mania.
 

NinoBrown

Active Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2007
Messages
3,129
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
35
Location
Toronto, Ontario
Never liked him. (At the time) He can outwrestle half of the roster even for a small guy. Can play a great heel, the goodie two shoes when he debuted and the serious heel he's done in recent years. Great on the mic. But I was never a fan.

Almost in every feud, I'd like his opponent more (except Big Show). Then the last year in the WWE really turned me off about the guy once I heard some of the fuckery that was going on backstage with him. Then he went to TNA, the dream feud with Samoa Joe was lackluster, created the garbage faction known as the MEM and the only good thing I probably ever liked about him was that he choose to go bald. Nowadays, he looks skinnier, more pale, just doesn't look as healthy as he used to.

But he is probably #4 or #5 if we're talking about the greatest wrestlers in the 2000's.