So why has Randy Orton or Edge ever been given the title? Why would you ever argue for them to be champion? There should only be one champion in the WWE right no until the day that he retires by that logic, and that champion is John Cena, because he IS the face of the company... which you can only have 1 of.
Because there are times the are as over or right there, with John Cena.
And the crowd has been flat out amazed with the way Miz can make them hate him... Rock was FAR from the most over guy when he won his first title... from Austin, who was 4-5x more popular at that point than The Rock was.
Ok, lets say you're right, he was still the number 2 guy, not the number 7 guy like you say Miz is. HUGE difference.
Read on where I said, "but just because they didn't deserve it more than someone else doesn't mean they didn't deserve it". And once again, Miz had a memorable match in which he defeated DX...
Yes, that match will be on DVDs and highlight reels for decades to come, way more than HBK/Razor, HHH/Rock, and every Benoit/Angle match.
...btw, Triple H maybe had 2-3 EXCELLENT matches prior to his first title... he got a rub off of his heat with Shawn Michaels when he wanted to take the title and HBK wanted to be the top guy and people saw someone who was in position to hold down arguably the most deserving guy in the company.
Yeah his heat had nothing to do with the fact that he was feuding with Vince, stole his daughter, and kept DX going strong. It was allllllllllllll HBK....
The only person suggesting Miz is being carried by anyone is you. I saw a match on Raw with Daniel Bryan where Miz actually appeared to carry Bryan. "But he locked in a chinlock and laid still and didn't sell that he was trying to make his opponent tap". Just because a Randy Orton wants to sell a chinlock as a vicious move doesn't mean everyone has to.
Actually, you and a lot of others keep saying "hes improving, hes getting there" etc. Ranny Orton doesn't sell a chinlock "more viciously" he sells it like he's actually trying to take his opponent out, you know, LIKE YOURE SUPPOSED TO.
There are hundreds of wrestlers who applied chinlocks just the same as Miz does... Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Steve Austin, The Rock, CM Punk, Edge... to name a few. It's used more as a move to hold your opponent down while you begin to recuperate a little bit rather than to sell an attempt at making the opponent submit. Okay, good for the guys who use it the way you prefer it to be used... I'd honestly prefer for a standard suplex to be more of a vertical suplex rather than a snap suplex... but I won't bash the hell out of every guy who uses a snap suplex.
Whats the point of a match? Every match? To win. So every move SHOULD be treated as such. When you godbrick it like Miz does, it shows you dont know what the fuck youre doing in the ring and you dont know how to tell a story. Miz doesnt look like hes trying to beat his opponent, he looks like hes going through his script. The good ones, ones who deserve to be champion, know how to make it look good.
Rey and Eddie were the most over with the hispanic fans; Eddie wasn't garnering more heat than a lot of people... he DAMN sure wasn't the top heel or the face of the company... neither was Rey.
Yeah, everyone who was going nuts for him on SD was hispanic. I totally remember all 5 hispanics in Tornoto coming out to see him and carrying him for the whole show.
There aren't that many faces close to being as over as Miz. There's John Cena and then there's nobody. You can argue Triple H but he has ONLY just come back. Rey gets love from the hispanic crowds... some from the rest... Miz gets heat from EVERYONE. His heat is universal. The only heel wrestler with more heat than Miz is CM Punk.
Edge, Cena, HHH, Punk, Kofi, Taker, and Orton, all are more over than Miz. When Orton attacked Punk out of the crowd this week on Raw, you heard the crowd AUDIBLY pop, like they did when HHH came out to interrupt Taker. Why? Because people give a fuck about those two feuds. And people care about Cena and Miz too, but only because Rock is there.
As if it has had any value since Benoit held it anyways (and even then, it was already devalued from the constant whoring it had back and forth).
Using that logic, the title lost value when it was going back and forth to people in the 90s. Oh wait that doesn't fit your narrative....feel free to ignore that little fact.
Miz is over... he's just not over with YOU.
But not as over as 3 other heels (since you said hes the 4th) and not as over as at least three faces. YEAH COME OUT AND SEE THE 4th BEST BAD GUY!!!! WOOOOOOO!!!
You know how many people sincerely despise having John Cena in the title picture at all?
Yep, that's why people react when he comes out as opposed to the semi and sporadic boos the 4th heel in the company gets.
Yet that's the face of the company... he's arguably the most popular guy in the WWE since The Rock. People don't want to see him as champion, but more people do.
But people want to see him. Know how I know? I have ears....
There are people who hate Miz (not heat-wise, genuinely hate him) and then there are far more people who think he's one of the most incredible heels in the last 5 years, even if he is a slight ripoff of Jericho 2007.
People who are so desperate to see something NEW that they will justify any jobber holding the title? Yeah, those people.
Edge has never been a #1 or #2. He's been a #2 heel possibly, but still behind the top 3 faces and the top heel... ESPECIALLY when he got his first title.
Even if I bought your "He was never a number two but me might have been" backwards logic, he still did more to prove he could carry the title transitionally, with his TLC matches, his feuds with Angle, his making garbage angles work, that he could at least hold it for a month. Then he got his title and that was it.
When Triple H got his first title, he was nowhere, ABSOLUTELY nowhere near top 5 in the company.
Austin, Rock aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand?
Taker's a legend, but his first title run as Taker? You know where he was in the company on a legitimate scale? Behind Hogan, Flair, Piper, Savage, Mr. Perfect, Ted DiBiase, Bret Hart, Ultimate Warrior, Ricky Steamboat... that's WAY under your standards.
Thats why the crowd was 60/40 in terms of face heat when he won his first title....Not according to me, to Hogan and Taker. Clearly people were clamoring to see Ricky spit fire instead...
When Brock got his, he wasn't a 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7 in the company.
Not when he was making the crowd pop Austin style during dark matches against jobbers. He was getting a Goldberg reaction.
Rock was under a few people... he was rising fast (much like Miz) but he wasn't the most over face or heel. Austin was the face of the company at that time... by your logic, why would you take the belt off of the face of your company?
To give it to the number two guy so he can feud with the number three guy while your top guy feuds with someone else to see if THEY can get over and take that number two or one spot.
But no, you're right, lets just give the title to anyone we want to make a star. Hey, Santino is way more over than almost anyone, despite the garbage hes been doing, lets give him the title. Hes not John Cena and he gets a great reaction (which are your only two requirements) Or even better, lets give the title to Kofi. Nevermind the fact he hasn't drawn shit on his own yet, he gets a great reaction and he's not John Cena. Or....oooo...lets give the title to Wade Barrett. He got mad heat as the leader of the Nexus and he's NOT JOHN CENA!!!
Just because it's different doesn't make it good.