Welcome to the Hamptons: Revenge Mafia Game Thread

[Chris]

Yeah I still think I agree with this

a claim would help tho

this was N1 right?

Yeah so no one would have used a role yet to need to be motivated like was considered...maybe a gift giver type thing is the only scum role I've really thought that could fit?

 

[Poyser]

Yeah that makes sense. I still feel there's more value in resolving this claim from CP as the only way it makes any reasonable sense is if Chris is lying.

Scum aren't going blind compel someone to use a role on a teammate nor would they blindly redirect anyone there so that can be ruled out. + you claimed a bus driver, right Poyser?

If CP had an info role then he should be lynched because he was sat on information for the entire day phase whilst the Juice drama went on and the whole debacle with Joe's claim.

This severely limits the roles he can claim which makes his fake much riskier if he is scum.

If he was a protective role, he would have claimed as such with the reasoning he was protecting someone who was being read by pretty much everyone as town and no-one would have really cared. Especially so considering the fact scum had a seraph flip.

This is my issue too. There’s no way scum just compel somebody to use a role they don’t know about on their teammate lol

 

[Poyser]

What's a second vote on Alco gonna hurt Poyser

It’s just odd because you agreed that a claim from CP would be good but then you pushed a lynch wagon further forward lol. I’m trying to make sense of it

 

[Poyser]

Yeah so no one would have used a role yet to need to be motivated like was considered...maybe a gift giver type thing is the only scum role I've really thought that could fit?

Yeah and he probably isn’t gonna wanna claim it if that’s what it is

 

[Evans]

This is my issue too. There’s no way scum just compel somebody to use a role they don’t know about on their teammate lol

Exactly, I think the compel bit was a huge reach and a desperate big play by him. Odo gave a meta here for CP which I think fits perfectly CPs play here.

I'm still backing that scum have inactives and that's why CP has "noped" the game so far and just been taunting about me being right on my read lol and why Juice wasn't reigned in (which was good for her in the end as she did do well to get town reads from the big names in the section).

I think it's more likely CP is scum than any roles became involved to affect results.

What roles can/are scum aligned usually that would require visiting a teammate?

I suppose we need to factor in this is a Smark game too and will have intricately designed roles/abilities that interact with flavour too.

For CP to be scum and Chris to be town, CP would have to know he would be next when chris flips ... he’s not a risk taker in that way until the games basically lost in his eyes, and then he’ll cut loose and try to make big plays

scum aren’t there yet

 

[Chris]

It’s just odd because you agreed that a claim from CP would be good but then you pushed a lynch wagon further forward lol. I’m trying to make sense of it

Idk man it just feels weird voting for someone I don't think is scum when I can just be like "bro claim" I guess I can put the fear of him with a little bold vote if I really need to tho


Vote CP

 

[Tweet]

Any.thoughts on who it is

None, I say let scum and the SK worry about each other.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Idk man it just feels weird voting for someone I don't think is scum when I can just be like "bro claim" I guess I can put the fear of him with a little bold vote if I really need to tho


Vote CP

 

[Tweet]

Vote Alco

A claim from CP would be nice to clear some things up but I still don't see him being scum with everything that happened yesterday.

Err scuse me?

You don't think CP is scum despite the fact that he claims the tracker result you got that involved him is a lie? In other words you trust him to be town over yourself?

 

[Tweet]

Idk man it just feels weird voting for someone I don't think is scum when I can just be like "bro claim" I guess I can put the fear of him with a little bold vote if I really need to tho


Vote CP

Eeeeggghhhh....

No.

Just...

No.

 

[Chris]

Err scuse me?

You don't think CP is scum despite the fact that he claims the tracker result you got that involved him is a lie? In other words you trust him to be town over yourself?

Until we know his claim I'm pretty sure there's plenty other variables that makes it where it's not CP or me lol

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Err scuse me?

You don't think CP is scum despite the fact that he claims the tracker result you got that involved him is a lie? In other words you trust him to be town over yourself?

Are you saying CP or Alco said that im confused

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Nvm chris just answered

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Fyi my girl is coming down at 4 so i may not be on

 

[Poyser]

Exactly, I think the compel bit was a huge reach and a desperate big play by him. Odo gave a meta here for CP which I think fits perfectly CPs play here.

I'm still backing that scum have inactives and that's why CP has "noped" the game so far and just been taunting about me being right on my read lol and why Juice wasn't reigned in (which was good for her in the end as she did do well to get town reads from the big names in the section).

I think it's more likely CP is scum than any roles became involved to affect results.

What roles can/are scum aligned usually that would require visiting a teammate?

I suppose we need to factor in this is a Smark game too and will have intricately designed roles/abilities that interact with flavour too.

Well the gift giver idea is really the only thing I can make sense of, unless it really was a motivator. Like I don’t see it being protection because nobody was gonna shoot her