The Rated R CMStar
Guest

Out of all the examples you could use of pathetic babyfaces(CM Punk, John Cena), HBK is by any means, not in the concept you used it, one to use. Or maybe a babyface who says he will never forgive someone, and that wants to disfigure you is the same as someone who says congratulations to the champion and hey man, you deserved it.
As for Edge face, it would be fresh, but first, WWE needs him heel. Case you didn't notice, without Umaga, SD only has Big Show as a credible main event heel, and even that's arguable. Instead, put him as a face and you will have him behind HHH and Taker, maybe even Jeff Hardy.
Also, when he comes back, he needs to go against Taker or HHH, not out of a sudden, and in random fashion, MVP.
As for Edge face, it would be fresh, but first, WWE needs him heel. Case you didn't notice, without Umaga, SD only has Big Show as a credible main event heel, and even that's arguable. Instead, put him as a face and you will have him behind HHH and Taker, maybe even Jeff Hardy.
Also, when he comes back, he needs to go against Taker or HHH, not out of a sudden, and in random fashion, MVP.