Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Marty McFourth]

I think a X-Shot Watcher and JOAT with Watcher ability can co-exist. It depends. I think we don't lynch Blaine today. Like Curry says, Grim has to prove his role usage now.

Vote Alco

Let's push someone that had dodgy interactions, wish has merit now that T-Pein has flipped.

 

[Rugrat]

With the RB dead he'll have to back up the watcher claim and it wouldn't have been all that weird if he had claimed roles other than watcher though (like the Doc/Cop which he can fake fine enough).

it's not hard to fake watcher results

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Eh...

I'm fine with the Alco direction I suppose.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Is it outside the realm of plausibility for Blaine to be scum JOAT?

 

[Curry]

it's not hard to fake watcher results

It's definitely hard to be confident you can be right once everyone knows you're going to be giving watcher results at some stage.

 

[Rugrat]

It's definitely hard to be confident you can be right once everyone knows you're going to be giving watcher results at some stage.

There's only going to be a handful of active roles. You can be reasonably confident on who will and won't be visited too. the roletracker can alert you to who's visiting who, too.

 

[Curry]

Is it outside the realm of plausibility for Blaine to be scum JOAT?

No, that'd be reasonable enough with different roles. Watch/track could still work but not doc/cop. Could have stuff like a busdrive or an execute.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Is it outside the realm of plausibility for Blaine to be scum JOAT?

No, but I don't think we lynch him today. We could always come back to it pending on what happens. The way Blaine claimed is just striking me as town, even though it's a role I usually associate with a scum team.

What are your thoughts on him copping me? You reckon he would fake that result as scum?

 

[Rugrat]

Also the role being called Doctor not Bodyguard too

I reckon T-Pein helped him come up with it in the QT as he's been playing in fagbagarden and it's called doc not BG there

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

No, that'd be reasonable enough with different roles. Watch/track could still work but not doc/cop. Could have stuff like a busdrive or an execute.

That's what I'm thinking. It'd be pretty easy for scum to lie about cop results tbh, since they have the virtue of being informed. The only way it would backfire is if they say the serial killer is town, and the SK would never out themselves to lynch scum.

 

[Curry]

There's only going to be a handful of active roles. You can be reasonably confident on who will and won't be visited too. the roletracker can alert you to who's visiting who, too.

For a little side-game, fake watcher results for last night on myself and on Barry and we'll see how they hold up once we learn more.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Could ya just not use the word, Rug?

 

[Curry]

T-Pein was on a team with a BG though so surely he'd know that's more common in this section?

 

[Rugrat]

For a little side-game, fake watcher results for last night on myself and on Barry and we'll see how they hold up once we learn more.

he doesn't have to come up with them now, he might only have to in a few days time

 

[Kajuh]

Didn't Poyser fake being JOAT as scum recently? Maybe that was one of the fakes that he gave scum