Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Rugrat]

Why are you reading Blaine town off so little? There's literally zero reason to be reading him town, at all. role soft or not, Blaine does that as either alignment.

Ive never seen him as scum and it doesn’t strike me as the sort of thing he’d do as scum

 

[Evans]

I’m like 83% sure Barry is scum here

 

[Evans]

Duel Barry

@Poyser @The Great One



like this is how sure I am

 

[Tweet]

Why and why?

 

[Evans]

Why and why?

His play to me feels copy & pasted from Star Wars and he was scum. From the fluffy entrance, minor inconsistencies around his posts / points to telling players to calm down jokingly.

 

[Curry]

If you're looking at the difference between Barry's thought on RR/Tweet does that mean you think one is a scummate?

(I assume based on the fact he went for RR rather than Tweet you'd be thinking Tweet but that doesn't seem such a solid line to me)

 

[Bobby Barrows]

What do you find bad about Rugrat joining a wagon and then getting a town read from Blaines reaction?

You don’t seem bothered that Tweet has reached the same conclusion without voting. Can you elaborate?

Well, let's follow my train of logic here, shall we?

1.) Blaine claims to not be vanilla townie. This is a dumb move to do as either alignment but it's not out of the realm of plausibility for scum Blaine to say this because, as I've mentioned, he's an erratic player.

2.) Both Flay and Rugrat vote him. Flay votes him because he wants a claim. Rugrat votes him for ?? reasons.

3.) Rugrat says Blaine is town. Now here's where my logic lies: If Rugrat thought Blaine was town, why would he vote him in the first place? Wouldn't Rugrat just say, "I think Blaine is town?" and leave it at that? He claims that the vote is so others can read Blaine, but not everyone reads Blaine town because it's such a preposterous thing.

4.) When the Blaine wagon obviously isn't taking off, Rugrat takes his vote off and continue the narrative that it was all in service of town.

I don't see town Rugrat voting for someone he thinks is town off the bat.

 

[Curry]

Also I suppose for the sake of formalities you should claim whatever you think we need to know.

 

[Tweet]

Why do these duelists always make me choose between two town leans lmao

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Duel Barry

@Poyser @The Great One



like this is how sure I am

Why?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Like what the fuck, dude? Didn't even give me a chance to qualify my points.

 

[Curry]

Well, let's follow my train of logic here, shall we?

1.) Blaine claims to not be vanilla townie. This is a dumb move to do as either alignment but it's not out of the realm of plausibility for scum Blaine to say this because, as I've mentioned, he's an erratic player.

2.) Both Flay and Rugrat vote him. Flay votes him because he wants a claim. Rugrat votes him for ?? reasons.

3.) Rugrat says Blaine is town. Now here's where my logic lies: If Rugrat thought Blaine was town, why would he vote him in the first place? Wouldn't Rugrat just say, "I think Blaine is town?" and leave it at that? He claims that the vote is so others can read Blaine, but not everyone reads Blaine town because it's such a preposterous thing.

4.) When the Blaine wagon obviously isn't taking off, Rugrat takes his vote off and continue the narrative that it was all in service of town.

I don't see town Rugrat voting for someone he thinks is town off the bat.

TAT/RR were voting Blaine before he claimed non-VT

He claimed non-VT in response to pressure and RR took that reaction as a sign of him being town.

 

[Evans]

If you're looking at the difference between Barry's thought on RR/Tweet does that mean you think one is a scummate?

(I assume based on the fact he went for RR rather than Tweet you'd be thinking Tweet but that doesn't seem such a solid line to me)

The fact he was willing to sheep onto the Rugrat wagon but was fine with Tweet making the same conclusion over very little was the icing on the cake for me tbh.

I don’t any thoughts about his team mates, I’m just confident he’s scum lol

 

[Bobby Barrows]

TAT/RR were voting Blaine before he claimed non-VT

He claimed non-VT in response to pressure and RR took that reaction as a sign of him being town.

Okay, reading back, Rugrat and Flay's vote are even worse. Blaine is 15, he was born in 2005. What the fuck are they voting him for?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

The fact he was willing to sheep onto the Rugrat wagon but was fine with Tweet making the same conclusion over very little was the icing on the cake for me tbh.

I don’t any thoughts about his team mates, I’m just confident he’s scum lol

I'm the Watcher you asshole.