this was on the sun website
WWE UNFORGIVEN may have seen wrestling records broken, but it certainly won't set any itself.
Going into the show there was only one match we wanted to see - John Cena v Randy Orton.
Sadly that was probably the worst of the lot.
Cena's run of amazing main events was ruined by bad wrestling and even worse booking, as The Champ was disqualified after just eight minutes.
Before we discuss the contest though, a word on John's achievement.
By retaining the title, which can't change hands on disqualification, it means by the time Raw rolls around next Monday he would have held the belt for 372 days.
That gives Cena the longest title reign since Hulk Hogan's 1984-1988 golden period.
It will also give him the sixth most impressive run in history trailing only Bruno Sammartino twice (2,803 and 1,237 days), Bob Backlund (2,135), Hulk Hogan (1,474) and Pedro Morales (1,027).
That is some achievement, given how often titles change hands in the modern era, especially considering he has now held the gold for a longer unbroken period than Bret Hart (248), Shawn Michaels (231), Steve Austin (175) and Triple H (118).
Most of his matches in that time have been strong, especially his title-win over Edge and previous defences against Michaels, Umaga and Orton.
Sadly his Unforgiven bout will not sit alongside those on a Best Of DVD.
To even call it a match is a stretch, it was more like a Raw segment.
Cutting a short story even shorter, Cena went into the match angry with Randy for attacking his father a few weeks ago.
So after a few wrestling moves he repeatedly punched Orton in the corner, while the ref told him to stop, and ended up getting disqualified.
It means the great feud continues and we'll get Orton v Cena again in a Last Man Standing match at No Mercy, although that will be little comfort to the American fans who paid around £20 to watch this PPV.
Batista had a better night.
The Animal broke an unwanted record of title-match losses and actually managed to make a fight featuring Great Khali interesting.
Big Dave has been involved in every Smackdown heavyweight title contest on PPV since August 2006, including losing the belt at WrestleMania on April 1 2007 and then failing in seven consecutive shots at the belt.
All that changed at Unforgiven though, as he won the gold by pinning Khali in a three-way also featuring Rey Mysterio.
It will never go down as a classic, but the three had an entertaining outing which ended when Batista powerbombed Mysterio onto Khali then hit a spinebuster on the giant and pinned him.
A MISMATCH ... Triple H's victory over Carlito was never in doubt
A CERTAINTY ... Triple H's victory
over Carlito was never in doubt
The third title match on the show saw ECW champion CM Punk defeat Elijah Burke, who was subbing for the suspended John Morrison.
A good wrestling match, fans never got into it as there was never any danger of Punk losing.
The same can be said for contests involving the returning Undertaker and Triple H - they were always going to win.
Even with Carlito being allowed to use any weapon he wanted against Hunter, everyone knew that match would always end in a Pedigree and a three-count.
And anyone who thought Mark Henry could defeat Undertaker needed their heads testing.
Triple H's bout was passable, but Taker's was terrible.
He and Henry just didn't gel and the totally dead crowd made things even worse.
The audience were quiet throughout the night - unsurprising given what was on offer.
Hamstrung by steroid suspensions, plus disputes with Booker T and Ric Flair, the card was stripped of star power.
MVP and Hardy played reluctant Smackdown tag champions well in retaining their belts and women's champion Candice Michelle beating Beth Phoenix told a good tale.
Sadly in both cases, again, the storytelling was better than the wrestling.
Lance Cade & Trevor Murdoch beating Paul London & Brian Kendrick for the Raw tag straps was probably the best match on the show, but nowhere near the best of the year.
What Unforgiven did well was really develop feuds with good video packages and, in most cases, match layout.
Sadly the PPV was all build up and no bite.
We give Unforgiven 6 out of 10.