The Official 2024-25 MLB Offseason Discussion Thread

[Storm Trooper]

But there needs to be a minimum of what is spent. Pretty sure that that contract yearly is more that the Pirates would spend.

oh I agree about a minimum to an extent. Should be low but there should be one.

Yamamoto (Japan), Blake Snell, Cody Bellinger and Jordan Montgomery are the next crop of top free agents.

And my Tigers have no shot in hell in any of them lol.

And I guess the argument for a cap of a max is to "balance" things in regards to market size. Since large markets have a major advantage in spending capital, so while yes, players can earn what they want, it also becomes discouraging as a fan if a team can pay a handful of big free agent players double a team's entire payroll if they want.

Who's fault is it that some teams don't spend money? Not the players fault and damn sure not the fans fault. The only people to be blamed are the owners. Every owner can afford the free agent deals players are signing, even Ohtani. They choose not to.

 

[Rosie]

To a degree, I get it. But also there is more that goes into paying for a team than just salaries. This is the approx value of each MLB team. As you can see there's some really low teams, a bunch in the middle, then we get some spiking with the top two big market teams/teams with history with teams who are almost always contenders, on top. A min, I agree. Even if a team is outright tanking, you still should have to at least TRY to spend something, but a cap of some kind, even if it is high, may ease the feeling of small market teams having an uphill battle when it comes to signing free agents.

 

[Tyler2]

Surprised my Rays aren't at the very bottom honestly. Still mad they took Smell out in that World Series

 

[#Waddles]

oh I agree about a minimum to an extent. Should be low but there should be one.


Who's fault is it that some teams don't spend money? Not the players fault and damn sure not the fans fault. The only people to be blamed are the owners. Every owner can afford the free agent deals players are signing, even Ohtani. They choose not to.

?
Why am I quoted...?

 

[Deadd2009]

Sources: Ohtani can opt out if Dodgers execs exit

Shohei Ohtani's historic contract with the Dodgers allows him to opt out if owner Mark Walter or president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman loses his role with the team, sources confirmed to ESPN.

www.espn.com

 

[#Waddles]

Only won 1 ring. For shame.

 

[Deadd2009]

Rays president threatens to reject new stadium deal if St. Petersburg officials demand name change

Brian Auld said keeping the "Tampa Bay" name "screams inclusive welcomeness"

www.cbssports.com

 

[Hidden Blaze]

https://x.com/braves/status/1736198592799338734?s=46&t=9Qzx0E_MsP62XKjeUO5dug

 

[Doom]

https://x.com/braves/status/1736198592799338734?s=46&t=9Qzx0E_MsP62XKjeUO5dug

Congrats Acuna!

 

[Rosie]

Yamamoto to LA also... Between him and Ohtani, they are paying over 1 billion dollars. For fuck's sake.

 

[Rosie]

Okay. Yep. NOW I want some sort of Salary cap for the MLB.

 

[Apoho Creed]

I speak for everyone with the News on Yamamoto to the Dodgers apparently fuck the Dodgers to the highest of levels. They have seemly an Ace Pitcher now because God knows their Rotation is terrible going into the Season. The Offense outside of the Top 4 or so is trash and hopefully the Teams with more of a balanced with their Offense and their Pitching Staff/Bullpen shows them up when it matters.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

You literally said you want a salary call that's pro owner. Plyers don't want a cap cause it limits what they can earn.

Except it doesn't. It just keeps teams from hoarding giant contracts, bruh. They can get fat ass contracts elsewhere. Big Market Teams already have a massive advantage when it comes to giving out contracts like they're candy while smaller market teams are forced to have to scout and create home-grown talent and hope that these players don't go out to free agency and sign with other big market teams.

The MLB especially makes it so playing in a small market is a disadvantage.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Okay. Yep. NOW I want some sort of Salary cap for the MLB.

Yep, when the Dodgers can pay upwards of $1 Billion alone on contracts, the league needs to step in and make it so these teams can't just buy out the best players.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Except it doesn't. It just keeps teams from hoarding giant contracts, bruh. They can get fat ass contracts elsewhere. Big Market Teams already have a massive advantage when it comes to giving out contracts like they're candy while smaller market teams are forced to have to scout and create home-grown talent and hope that these players don't go out to free agency and sign with other big market teams.

The MLB especially makes it so playing in a small market is a disadvantage.

And to expand on this, Ohtani's contract makes it impossible for small market teams to compete when they can't afford to defer contracts the way the Yankees or Dodgers can.

If you think that's anti-player, go fuck yourself I guess. It's not about the owners, it's about league parity.