- Before the show, the whole roster came out for a 10-bell salute for Mike Graham.
Singles Match
Su Yung def. Rhia O'Reilly
Singles Match
Brandi Wine def. Kimberly
Singles Match
Reby Sky def. Kellie Skater
Singles Match
Rain def. Christina Von Eerie
- After the match, Made in Sin ran in and attacked Von Errie, including April Hunter nailing her with a bat. Shazza McKenzie & Davina Rose ran in to make the save. Von Eerie then challenged Made in Sin to a 6-Woman Tag at SHINE #6 on January 11th, so it will be Von Eerie, McKenzie & Rose vs. All 3 members of Made in Sin.
Tag Team Match
Made In Sin (Allysin Kay & Taylor Made) (w/April Hunter) def. Davina Rose & Shazza McKenzie
- It was announced that SHINE #5 will take place on November 16th and SHINE #6 will take place on January 11th, 2013.
Singles Match
Mercedes Martinez def. Santana
Singles Match
Jessicka Havok def. Leva Bates
- After the match, Havok grabbed a steel chair and went to attack Leva with it until Reby Sky ran in and attacked Havok with a steel chair of her own. Sky then bulldogged Havok onto both steel chairs.
- It was announced that "The Wrestling Goodess" Athena will get the 1st shot at the SHIMMER Title against the winner of the main event on the 1st day of SHIMMER DVD Tapings next Saturday October 27th at the Berwyn Eagles Club in Berwyn, Illinois.
SHIMMER Championship Match
Saraya Knight (c) def. Jazz
- Jazz had the match & title won after hitting the Jazz Stinger, but then Mercedes Martinez & Rain came to ringside. While Mercedes had the referee distracted, Rain came in and nailed Jazz with a pair of brass knuckles, then put Saraya on top of Jazz for the pinfall.
