Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Chris]

Ah okay. You seem to be doing well for a newish guy.

My very first game, Tweet got me mislynched bc he said I was too good for a new player For context, I had played IRL mafia just a couple times like 8-9 years ago, but didn't know forum mafia existed until everyone came over here and started playing last December or so.

 

[RDK]

Yeah I’m not sure I buy the reaction to junks claim if that was his own role lol

this looks decent for Lethal especially given it was pre- heat on Poyser

 

[Tweet]

My very first game, Tweet got me mislynched bc he said I was too good for a new player For context, I had played IRL mafia just a couple times like 8-9 years ago, but didn't know forum mafia existed until everyone came over here and started playing last December or so.

 

[NotBrutus]

Any notable incidents that happened?

 

[RDK]

Not asking me but I'm gonna answer you in the affirmative, very unlikely we have 2 PGO-esque roles.

So what are your thoughts on the back of that scum flip that was lead by Odo and Junk?

 

[RDK]

whoever said gambit hasn't been great post-claim, that's spot on. albeit i skimmed the thread but i cannot recall a notable post.

having sat through a slog of an endgame with haza/jeff, i'm not feeling teh same vibes on them as townies. last game, haza made it pretty easy to read him a townie then i waffled on it because of paranoia. regarding jeff, he seemed more precise last game but i dont see the same sharpness last game.

lethal is top wagon and his claim appears to be legit. a non-town healer? probably not. if anyone is not town in that poisoner/healer dynamic, it's gonna be junk but the way the claim was done and presented, junk came off with towny vibes. as far day one goes, i think we're better off looking elsewhere.

I'm always easier to read as town as the game goes on and the pool narrows. You'll notice in past games I tend to lead less at the start and more at the end as town.

 

[Odo]

Imagine me actually playing the game early on instead of dicking around and getting scum read for it? What a world.

 

[Tweet]

Any notable incidents that happened?

You got daykilled, discuss

 

[RDK]

I think I like this post, I'd already pretty much forgotten about Gambit but he's not exactly moved mountains ever since he claimed.

Regarding Haza, I think it might be the case that losing the last game left him a little frustrated and maybe he doesn't have it in him to replicate that kinda effort this time. I don't find much reason to read him town for now but personally I don't expect him to be as assertive as last game even if he did draw town again.

Don't particularly like this post. I'm almost always assertive in any game I play so this smells fake

 

[Odo]

Unvote. Vote Jeff

reasons would be nice

Killjoy. You have a pretty severe lack of conviction in this game and it's throwing me. You seemed more punchy at the start of the last game

Would you say you're not a fan of my play

I've been on a few wagons up to this point, and see little value in rushing through a phase. not really sure how else to answer that other then I disagree

Just something I've picked up on on a re-read. You have stated/insinuated you're null on Tweet, Gambit, PHEN0M, Lethal and maybe more, I got distracted and stopped but you seemed more assured of yourself last time out

Eh, I took not giving it any thought as null but I can give you benefit of the doubt here just about

This was in reference to Lethal.

I'm not saying your reads may not have changed but it's a trend I picked up on

What does Doc's scum game look like, for those of us who haven't had the pleasure

Yeesh, this looks so fake to me

 

[Tweet]

Don't particularly like this post. I'm almost always assertive in any game I play so this smells fake

No you're not, you've had scum games that consisted of you telling your team to hard bus you, and games where your thread play amounted to promising you'll catch up without ever doing so.

 

[Odo]

Im really not seeing these Doc town reads you guys are dropping out there tbh

 

[RDK]

Welp since Jeff also seems to have IRL issues

unvote
vote Poyser

Knowing Poyser is scum now this is an interesting post.

You basically elected to join Odo and Big Man on a push of Poyser instead of going for your pool of "would wagon's". I'd like to think this makes you likely town as you'd probably just progress naturally into voting a would wagon read rather than a teammate. Seems unnecessary to do that unless you have great foresight.

 

[RDK]

No you're not, you've had scum games that consisted of you telling your team to hard bus you, and games where your thread play amounted to promising you'll catch up without ever doing so.

Can you link me to the last game on WS where I wasn't very assertive in your opinion. I feel like i'm always quite prominent because I've been trying to become less prominent particularly on day 1.

 

[RDK]

Well just so we are clear jeff’s RL stuff doesn’t mean he’s not scum lol

but does seem to suggest that pushing him in the immediate future isn’t really going to be fruitful unless you just lynch him

Weird point but if this was directed at Tweet or me and Tweet, I think the verbiage "unless you just lynch him" clears tweet as town