Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[RDK]

Make a case on mikey being town

He was pushing Guts over town alternatives earlier and giving reasoning for doing so for starters. He vibes similarly to the last game I played with him where I thought he seemed kind of lost which is also a slight town tell in itself.

I have him middle of the road on my Poe so not really sold either way if you could tell me your case on him being scum it would be very much appreciated.

 

[RDK]

I seem to remember a post jeff made where it looked, in retrospect, like he knew poyser was scum.

I quoted it but Jeff dismissed it as an in joke.

 

[Chris]

I quoted it but Jeff dismissed it as an in joke.

The "GOOD FRIEND" post right? I think that may have just been a joke tbh but if anything Jeff may have just already suspected Poyser as scum and was trying to get his attention.

 

[RDK]

@NotBrutus have you built your case on mikey yet

 

[NotBrutus]

He was pushing Guts over town alternatives earlier and giving reasoning for doing so for starters. He vibes similarly to the last game I played with him where I thought he seemed kind of lost which is also a slight town tell in itself.

I have him middle of the road on my Poe so not really sold either way if you could tell me your case on him being scum it would be very much appreciated.

Yeah because that makes him objectively town, he’s obviously gonna do that if he knows Doc is non-town (aka scum mate) Plus all he did was call Doc a fence sitter IIRC. He wanted to do a deeper dive on Doc and Ace, who were both heavily sussed at the time. Thinking this would buy him cheap town points.... not happening boyo.

 

[RDK]

Yeah because that makes him objectively town, he’s obviously gonna do that if he knows Doc is non-town (aka scum mate) Plus all he did was call Doc a fence sitter IIRC. He wanted to do a deeper dive on Doc and Ace, who were both heavily sussed at the time. Thinking this would buy him cheap town points.... not happening boyo.

I've never said he is town. I'm giving you a reasons for why he could be because you asked. He is in my PoE which I'm working to organize.

The longer it takes for you to make a case on him as your scum read the higher you are on that PoE. Still waiting

 

[NotBrutus]

I know what you said. I’m counter-claiming your points.

 

[NotBrutus]

I've never said he is town. I'm giving you a reasons for why he could be because you asked. He is in my PoE which I'm working to organize.

The longer it takes for you to make a case on him as your scum read the higher you are on that PoE. Still waiting

Oh no. I’m quivering in my boots.

 

[RDK]

Alright so Brutus is calling Mikey scum without a case

 

[Tweet]

Alright so Brutus is calling Mikey scum without a case

Yea I think after lynching Gambit, Brutus is next on my list. Brutus and Mikey are both completely null to me and Brutus sussing Mikey like this could be either a) scum trying to shoot for one of the few mislynches they can realistically still obtain or b) I could even see this being a distancing effort cause Brutus is sus of Mikey and only Mikey, if he was seriously scumhunting he'd probably have more than exactly one scum read and nothing else. At any rate I think Brutus is going after Mikey and Mikey himself has done nothing of the sort, so Brutus looks way worse in this.

 

[Tweet]

In case I die, don't forget that I copped TKOK non-Mafia which means he could technically be another indy. However if there's another indy type role, Barry would fill the slot of something like a even-night Arsonist + Bomb in my reads list, he's done nothing but make himself obvious non-scum by daring people to visit him but other than that his play seems to fit an indy who would like to fly under the radar and see the player numbers decrease.

Speaking of TKOK, it goes without saying that if we're looking for exactly the GF, the Cop result is null and void.

 

[Tweet]

Hm actually thinking about it, unless he has more roles it could just be that Barry is a town Bomb cause why would he want others to visit him to blow em up if it's almost certainly gonna get him lynched?

 

[RDK]

Hm actually thinking about it, unless he has more roles it could just be that Barry is a town Bomb cause why would he want others to visit him to blow em up if it's almost certainly gonna get him lynched?

This crossed my mind earlier.

And also yes TKOK town unless we are looking for exactly gf

 

[Tweet]

I'd say after lynching Gambit it's mass claim time?

 

[RDK]

I'd say after lynching Gambit it's mass claim time?

Maybe, but we likely still have some good roles to protect. I do think mass claim will be very useful when we do get around to it though.