Establish an identity for the show. If you want wrestling, watch Smackdown. If you want "sports entertainment", watch Raw.
Get rid of the IC belt and elevate Rhodes to the ME scene. ADR is a proven failure atm, and the taped Smackdown can let the young talent have a chance to shine. Use it as such.
Find something to do with all the squashers. Brodus Clay and Santino can continue their tag-team, Ryback can feud with Mark Henry if he's leaving the company, and Cesaro and Ohno can be a tag-team again.
Tag teams, obviously. Call up Reks and Hawkins. Use the Usos, Call up Tyson when Baretta or Gabriel get healthy.
Eventually turn Sheamus, Orton, Show, Daniel Bryan, Christian, and Mcintyre, among others. Way too many people on the wrong side of the fence. Have Show be the "massive obstacle" that all the young, undersized faces overcome since it's all he's good for. Wish Khali the best of luck in all his future endeavors.
Actual feuds. Ryback and Henry can simply feud over who the better big man is. Face Hunico can battle ADR in a rich vs poor storyline. Heel Sheamus can play an anti-american, setting up a Swagger face turn (Barrett would be better but he should be on Raw).
Show Superstars highlights. Just because there isn't enough time in the show doesn't mean the rest of the roster should be forgotten. If there's only time for one tag match, put another on Superstars and show us that they still exist.