Round 2: Quadrant 2 Matchup 8

[The New F'n Show]

Sheamus

Sheamus won the WWE title from John Cena on December 13th 2009 at TLC in a Tables Match. He lost the title back on February 21st 2010 at Elimination Chamber in an Elimination Chamber match also involving Triple H, Randy Orton, Ted DiBiase and Kofi Kingston. He won the title back on June 20th 2010 at Fatal Four Way in a match also involving Randy Orton and Edge. He lost the title to Orton on September 19th 2010 at Night of Champions in a Six Pack Challenge Elimination Match also involving Edge, John Cena, Chris Jericho, and Wade Barrett.

Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam won the WWE title from John Cena on June 11th 2006 at One Night Stand in an Extreme Rules match. He was awarded the ECW title by Paul Heyman on the June 13th 2006 ECW. He lost the WWE title to Edge on the July 3rd 2006 Raw in a triple threat match also involving Cena. He lost the ECW title to The Big Show in an Extreme Rules match on the July 4th 2006 ECW. He won the TNA title from AJ Styles on the April 19th 2010 Impact. He vacated the title due to a storyline injury on the August 19th 2010 Impact.

 

[PHX]

Funny enough both of their title reigns biggest highlight was the fact that they beat John Cena for it. RVD's was just a bigger deal so RVD.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

RVD is a midcarder who puts people over and Sheamus is a champion whenever he feels like it... I'm going with Sheamus.

 

[Keith]

Odd how Van Dam never won the origanal ECW Title. Really his three world title reigns didn't add up to much. I went Sheamus here.

 

[Deuce]

Sheamus won the championship early in his career and against John Cena! He has my vote for sure.

 

[Andrew]

Went Sheamus here.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Sheamus' reigns were a bit forgettable to me, so RVD.

 

[Keith]

I agree about Sheamus Scott, but would you not say the same about Van Dam's reigns? His WWE and ECW reigns were so short they didn't have much impact, and his TNA one was a total wash out.

 

[Troy]

Sheamus first title reign was more impressive than what RVD did with the title. I still wonder what might have been had RVD not been arrested for drug possession when he was ECW and WWE champion.

 

[The New F'n Show]

I agree about Sheamus Scott, but would you not say the same about Van Dam's reigns? His WWE and ECW reigns were so short they didn't have much impact, and his TNA one was a total wash out.

Can't disagree but RVD's win was historic. Sheamus win came out of nowhere. I like Sheamus a lot and hope he goes on to big things but RVD's reigns seemed a tad bit more important to me.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Sheamus by the slimiest of margins.