Round 1: Quadrant 6 Matchup 6

[The New F'n Show]

6. Bruiser Brody

11. Nigel McGuinness

 

[Chris]

Holy fuck this was hard. Brody may be the best brawler of all time, but I went with Nigel, the dude had it all.

 

[Heisenberg]

Bruiser Brody was a great character with a good size but I don't think he can compete with Nigel. Nigel McGuinness was a great wrestler and had good charisma, shame he never got to WWE and is now retired.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Brody dud what he was supposed to do. Come in to a territory destroy and then put over the champ. McGuinness had way more star potential. Nigel for me.

 

[chefboyardee]

im sorry.i know hes a legend but brody just isnt a guy you put as champ.mcguinness had no weaknesses,great talker,look,worker.charisma the guy had it all.im not convinced hes retired forever.hopefully he will comeback asap.

 

[BDC]

Style and mic skills. Not so sure about difference in ring skills. Nigel!

 

[Smartmark]

Nigel. But he's held one of the most prestigeous world titles in the world

 

[Canadian Pothead]

Nigel for me, the guy was so fucking talented. Shame he's retired now because I could have seen him with a World title in either TNA or WWE he was that good.

 

[The Cork]

Brody, not even close.

 

[AZUCAR!]

Nigel

 

[Tapout]

I didn't even think about it. Brody. 100 percent. Nigel I think never really had what it took to make it outside of the indies. His TNA run was not memorable at all.

 

[PHX]

Nigel makes much more sense when it comes to being a world champ.

 

[Shaun]

Nigel McGuinness, no questions asked. I see him being a dark horse in this tournament.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Well, I voted Brody. That maniac could have been a great monster champion.

 

[Keith]

I didn't even think about it. Brody. 100 percent. Nigel I think never really had what it took to make it outside of the indies. His TNA run was not memorable at all.

Did you not see his series with Angle then?

Both great in different ways, but I vote Nigel.