ROMANVM HISTORIVM: A Roman History Mafia Game Thread

[CraigPelton]

I dont understand how you think your case is solid, there are gaping holes lol

- Why would he blindly fake an odd night cop when its reasonable to believe that there may be an actual odd night cop?
- If he was going to fake it, why would he give a fake clear on you of all of the possible results and players?

no I'm thinking he's a scum odd night gunsmith and wang is the town even night gunsmith. Read my fucking posts dude

 

[Odo]

Vote Doddsy

 

[Odo]

That makes even less sense lmao

Youre taking away the possibility that he faked the role, which leaves only host interpretation of whether duellist shows up in a gunskith results or not ???

 

[CraigPelton]

I dont understand how you think your case is solid, there are gaping holes lol

- Why would he blindly fake an odd night cop when its reasonable to believe that there may be an actual odd night cop?
- If he was going to fake it, why would he give a fake clear on you of all of the possible results and players?

Also you're now the one expecting T-PEIN to make sense. My case doesn't depend on him making sense. It's based on the fact he explicitly implied I didn't have a killing role. How is this so hard to understand

 

[Odo]

Ie how would him supposedly giving a result you dont agree with lead you to think hes guilty, if you think hes an actual gunsmith

 

[CraigPelton]

That makes even less sense lmao

Youre taking away the possibility that he faked the role, which leaves only host interpretation of whether duellist shows up in a gunskith results or not ???

well barry wouldn't tell me if it would or not but I'm pretty sure it would since I have to be in the duel and there has to be a winner so I'm literally killing another player

 

[Odo]

Im asking you to present a coherent account of what you think actually happened.

You said you think hes a scum gunsmith, which means he would get a real result on you. How is his result not being what you expected indicative of his guilt? It would make sense if you thought he was faking, but youve explicitly said you dont think thats the case

 

[T-Pein™]

Also you're now the one expecting T-PEIN to make sense. My case doesn't depend on him making sense. It's based on the fact he explicitly implied I didn't have a killing role. How is this so hard to understand

But you say that you do have a killing role...
Wth?

I was just trying to get you to relax by thinking I town cleared you and then I was gonna tunnel you till you broke.

Imagine thinking T-P slips.
Imagine thinking T-P claims.

 

[RetepAdam.]

Magic/Peter, do you get any sense that CP is trying to bait a comment from TPein so stupid that it justifies him duelling him immediately?

No, I think he's just getting his energy back from being hungover and baffled that this is how he has to expend it.

 

[CraigPelton]

Im asking you to present a coherent account of what you think actually happened.

You said you think hes a scum gunsmith, which means he would get a real result on you. How is his result not being what you expected indicative of his guilt? It would make sense if you thought he was faking, but youve explicitly said you dont think thats the case

the role, not the target. He probably has another role he can't claim like Evans did but you can't exactly claim not to use a gunsmith n1

 

[CraigPelton]

No, I think he's just getting his energy back from being hungover and baffled that this is how he has to expend it.

bro I feel like I'm being gaslighted this seems OBVIOUS

 

[RetepAdam.]

are some of my posts not showing up or something

This board is weird with how pages update.

 

[CraigPelton]

@Showtime pls read my posts and tell me what you think

 

[CraigPelton]

unvote
vote doddsy

fine with this too btw

 

[T-Pein™]

I am confused,
He is saying I knew town has an odd cop.
How would I know he is odd cop?
Then he says I will claim to be even cop?
Wut.

Then he says he thinks I am mafia cop.
And then he says my fake town clear is fake because I did not read his actual role?
I said he isnt a killer but he says he is actually a killer.