Rate the Current Superstar: Nia Jax edition

[Sabretooth]

Not you too Deezy

did you really expect anything else

 

[Hidden Blaze]

did you really expect anything else

For once, I think Deezy actually has a good point.

 

[Sabretooth]

For once, I think Deezy actually has a good point.

this is what I get for running live discussions with you for years.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

this is what I get for running live discussions with you for years.

Still love you bro, but I gotta speak facts here. Nia ain't really all that good. Which you can see a lot of people agree by the low ratings she has gotten. Still love you tho no bro.

 

[Sabretooth]

Still love you bro, but I gotta speak facts here. Nia ain't really all that good. Which you can see a lot of people agree by the low ratings she has gotten. Still love you tho no bro.

lol to not get a rating? I don’t think so

 

[Hidden Blaze]

lol to not get a rating? I don’t think so

I mean they are plenty of people I don't rate. Mainly cause I forget too but I mean its better he doesn't rate, than drag the rating down correct? I can respect that.

 

[Sabretooth]

I mean they are plenty of people I don't rate. Mainly cause I forget too but I mean its better he doesn't rate, than drag the rating down correct? I can respect that.

pretty sure that’s not the point lol. I rather he rate her and drag her down then just say I’m not gonna rate her. I just think it’s stupid in general to say that any wrestler is a zero in everything.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

pretty sure that’s not the point lol. I rather he rate her and drag her down then just say I’m not gonna rate her. I just think it’s stupid in general to say that any wrestler is a zero in everything.

Fair enough. I just know if it was a wrestler I liked(not sure if you like Nia to much haha) I rather he not rate them and drag it down. If he said they suck to much to rate, whatever sure I be mad, but at least I know he doesn't fuck the rating up much. But hey we all see stuff different. I respect your view my brotha.

 

[DammitC]

Since this thread is still active, I might as well let you folks know that I just counted your delayed votes and I just updated the overall rankings in my most recent thread (which is on the Braun Strowman rating thread).

 

[Sabretooth]

Fair enough. I just know if it was a wrestler I liked(not sure if you like Nia to much haha) I rather he not rate them and drag it down. If he said they suck to much to rate, whatever sure I be mad, but at least I know he doesn't fuck the rating up much. But hey we all see stuff different. I respect your view my brotha.

No look at my ratings I’m not crazy about her lol. I just think that based on the fact that she had a few good feuds and matches that giving her 1s and 0s or not rating her is ridiculous.

 

[Hoss]

Well I can say that I gave her 1 for in-ring ability and charisma and I stand by it completely. For me, she has had 2 singles matches in her career that I liked. One against Rousey and one against Asuka. And those two aren't slouches so it's not like she's ever carried anyone. So, taking into account her shortage of good matches, and then factoring in that I can't think of one thing she's actually GOOD at in the ring, and then adding in how she's notorious for being unsafe, or at the very least clumsy and a bit stiff... 1 is as high as I can go. In the charisma department, again, I would have to reference the fact that I've never cared about any of her feuds PERSONALLY. And I think when you consider everyone she's worked with, and her distinct size and look, and the fact that she's had some potentially good material to work with, and people STILL have no interest in her? She obviously is not a charismatic person. I gave her a bit higher of a rating in mic skills because she can at least get through a promo without stumbling over her words or looking stupid, but as far cutting a promo that is gonna catch my attention, she is yet to come close to doing that. If you can't understand or respect that, it's really not my problem. I don't have anything against her on a personal level, I just think she's bad at this.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Look = 1. I get it, she's big, and she hasn't got the model physique. But a good monster heel does not parade out in an ill-fitting bodystocking while made up in the same style as the models are. Fuckin' Rosie Lottalove was better in this role, and that's because she didn't pretend to be something she wasn't.
In-Ring = 0. I actually want to give a negative number here. Someone so utterly careless, who refuses to not injure anyone she's with and is constantly given free passes, cannot be given a positive score for this category.
Charisma = 0. I also wanted to give a negative number here. She doesn't even generate X-Pac heat, only X-Pac apathy. Commentators keep telling me she's the Rock's cousin; she's clearly not related to the Rock, as there'd be at least some family resemblance in the charisma department.
Mic = 0.5. That half a point only exists because she has the ability to speak at all.

I do not like Nia Jax.

 

[Big Man]

the level of disrespect being shown in this thread is unreal.

 

[Sabretooth]

I find it hilarious she gets so much shit for injuring people when Owen Hart who’s considered one of the greatest wrestlers of all time injured stone cold so badly he had to retire early

 

[Hoss]

I find it hilarious she gets so much shit for injuring people when Owen Hart who’s considered one of the greatest wrestlers of all time injured stone cold so badly he had to retire early

I find it hilarious you can't differentiate between one very unfortunate botch on an already dangerous move and just being a reckless person who doesn't take care of your opponents.