Rate the Current Superstar: Jade Cargill edition

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Who should we rate next?


  • Total voters
    2

DammitC

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,660
Points
113
Age
27
Yea, it turns out that this AEW female talent managed to tie with Io Shirai on receiving the most votes; which means that we're also going to do her this week. It is now time to rate another current superstar. I'd like to thank those of you who participated in last week's threads. Remember that all of your votes DO matter, but please just try to be objective. Let's also try to get as many responses here as possible now, and PLEASE try to vote on my polls :eek:

As you already know by now at this point, Mansoor ended up being ranked at 64th place in the current section so far. Unfortunately for Mansoor, the ratings for his mic skills hurt him drastically. However, he did not seem to have any apparent strengths on any of the departments.

As you already know by now at this point, SANADA ended up being ranked at 21st place in the current section so far. Unfortunately for SANADA, the ratings for his mic skills hurt him dramatically. However, the Cold Skull did receive pretty damn good scores for his in-ring ability and his look/presence.

As you already know by now at this point, Gail Kim ended up being ranked at 7th place in the section for the women so far. Unfortunately for Gail, the ratings for her mic skills hurt her slightly. However, she did receive pretty damn good scores for her look/presence and her in-ring ability. I will repeat that Gail Kim is now tied with Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks, and Lacey Evans at 9th place for having the best look/presence compared to the rest of the other women rated so far. She also now has the 3rd highest score for having the best in-ring ability in comparison to the rest of the other female wrestlers rated already. Not only that, but Gail Kim is also now tied with Asuka at 10th place for having the most charisma compared to the rest of the other female talents.

Classic:


Kurt Angle: 9.2 (Look/Presence 9.0, In-Ring Ability 9.6, Charisma 9.2, Mic Skills 8.9)
Undertaker: 9.0 (Look/Presence 9.9, In-Ring Ability 8.5, Charisma 9.5, Mic Skills 8.1)
Shawn Michaels: 8.9 (Look/Presence 8.6, In-Ring Ability 9.5, Charisma 9.1, Mic Skills 8.4)
Triple H: 8.9 (Look/Presence 9.4, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.9, Mic Skills 8.9)
Eddie Guerrero: 8.8 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 9.7, Charisma 9.3, Mic Skills 8.0)
Mick Foley: 8.7 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 9.5, Mic Skills 9.6)
Bret Hart: 8.5 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 9.8, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 7.2)
HHH: 8.4 (8.9, 7.9, 8.4, 8.4)
BH: 8.4 (8.6, 9.6, 8.2, 7.1)

Kane: 8.0 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 7.1, Charisma 8.4, Mic Skills 7.1)
Owen Hart: 7.6 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 9.1, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.5)

Current:

Hiromu Takahashi: 8.9 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 9.2, Charisma 9.5, Mic Skills 8.8)
Kazuchika Okada: 8.8 (Look/Presence 9.0, In-Ring Ability 9.7, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 7.3)
Bryan Danielson: 8.7 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 9.7, Charisma 8.9, Mic Skills 8.4)
Hiroshi Tanahashi: 8.6 (Look/Presence 8.7, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 7.5)
BD: 8.5 (7.5, 9.6, 8.8, 8.2)
Edge: 8.5 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 8.9)
Randy Orton: 8.5 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.4, Mic Skills 7.9)
CM Punk: 8.5 (Look/Presence 6.8, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 9.2, Mic Skills 9.7)
Brock Lesnar: 8.4 (Look/Presence 10.0, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 8.6, Mic Skills 6.2)
Will Ospreay: 8.3 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 9.6, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 7.4)
Chris Jericho: 8.3 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 9.3, Mic Skills 9.1)
E: 8.3 (8.2, 8.0, 8.4, 8.7)
Samoa Joe: 8.3 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 8.4, Mic Skills 8.7)
RO: 8.3 (9.0, 8.2, 8.2, 7.7)
Kota Ibushi: 8.2 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.8, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 6.7)
MJF: 8.2 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 9.5)
Christian Cage: 8.2 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 8.3)
FTR: 8.2 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 9.6, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 7.6)
Matt Riddle: 8.2 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 8.6, Mic Skills 7.4)
Pac: 8.2 (Look/Presence 8.7, In-Ring Ability 9.5, Charisma 7.4, Mic Skills 7.0)
Jay White: 8.1 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 7.8)
Drew McIntyre: 8.0 (Look/Presence 9.4, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 7.2)
WO: 8.0 (7.9. 9.4, 7.7, 7.1)
R-Truth: 8.0 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 6.8, Charisma 8.9, Mic Skills 8.6)
SANADA: 8.0 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 8.0, Mic Skills 6.7)
Jon Moxley: 8.0 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 7.3, Charisma 8.2, Mic Skills 8.5)
AJ Styles: 8.0 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 9.4, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 7.0)
Seth Rollins: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 7.2)
Cody Rhodes: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 7.9)
MR: 7.9 (8.1, 8.2, 8.3, 6.9)
Ricky Starks: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 8.4, Mic Skills 8.8)
Elias: 7.9. (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 6.3, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 8.5)
DM: 7.9 (9.3, 7.9, 7.3, 6.9)
Cameron Grimes: 7.8 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 7.9)
Kenny Omega: 7.8 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 9.1, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 6.6)
Austin Theory: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 7.1)
Malakai Black: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 7.3)
ftr: 7.8 (7.4, 9.3, 7.2, 7.1)
SR: 7.8 (7.7, 8.8, 7.6, 7.0)

Dolph Ziggler: 7.7 (Look/Presence 7.3, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 7.5)
Kevin Owens: 7.7 (Look/Presence 6.1, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 8.4)
WALTER: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.7, In-Ring Ability 9.2, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 5.7)
Robert Roode: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 7.3)
Chad Gable: 7.7 (Look/Presence 6.8, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 7.6)
Bron Breakker: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 7.5, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 6.8)
Jeff Hardy: 7.6 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.5, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 6.3)
AJS: 7.6 (7.2, 9.0, 7.6, 6.7)
The Miz: 7.6 (Look/Presence 6.9, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 8.9)
Finn Balor: 7.6 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 8.5, Charisma 8.0, Mic Skills 6.3)
Sami Zayn: 7.6 (Look/Presence 5.8, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 8.5)
Tommaso Ciampa: 7.6 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 7.3)
Rey Mysterio: 7.6 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 8.2, Mic Skills 5.6)
SZ: 7.5 (5.6, 8.4, 7.6, 8.3)
Big E: 7.5 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 7.2)
Roman Reigns: 7.5 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.3)
RR: 7.5 (9.0, 7.3, 7.2, 6.4)
TM: 7.5 (6.7, 6.4, 7.9, 8.8)

Adam Page: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 6.4)
Sheamus: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 6.7, Mic Skills 6.8)
Damian Priest: 7.2 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 6.4)
AP: 7.2 (7.3, 7.8, 7.4, 6.2)
Darby Allin: 7.2 (Look/Presence 6.9, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 8.0, Mic Skills 5.6)
Mustafa Ali: 7.2 (Look/Presence 6.7, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 6.8, Mic Skills 7.0)
Joe Gacy: 7.1 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 7.9)
Claudio Castagnoli: 7.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 9.1, Charisma 6.5, Mic Skills 4.6)
Adam Cole: 7.1 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 7.7)
Young Bucks: 7.0 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 8.5, Charisma 7.4, Mic Skills 6.2)
Bobby Lashley: 7.0 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.2, Mic Skills 5.0)
Eddie Kingston: 7.0 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 5.8, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 9.0)
KO: 6.9 (6.7, 8.4, 6.8, 5.8)
Powerhouse Hobbs: 6.8 (Look/Presence 8.7, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 6.3, Mic Skills 5.4)
Apollo Crews: 6.8 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.9)
Shinsuke Nakamura: 6.7 (Look/Presence 6.8, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 4.5)
AC: 6.7 (4.5, 7.5, 7.5, 7.4)
BL: 6.7 (8.9, 7.3, 5.9, 4.8)
EK: 6.6 (4.6, 5.4, 7.8, 8.5)

Shelton Benjamin: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 5.4, Mic Skills 5.1)
BC: 6.3 (6.8, 6.5, 5.6, 6.3)
Matt Hardy: 6.3 (Look/Presence 5.8, In-Ring Ability 5.9, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 6.4)
DP: 6.2 (7.4, 6.6, 5.7, 5.1)
YB: 6.2 (5.1, 7.6, 6.5, 5.5)

Jinder Mahal: 6.2 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 5.7, Charisma 5.6, Mic Skills 5.4)
Baron Corbin: 6.2 (Look/Presence 6.6, In-Ring Ability 6.3, Charisma 5.5, Mic Skills 6.2)
Mansoor: 5.3 (Look/Presence 5.8, In-Ring Ability 5.7, Charisma 5.1, Mic Skills 4.5)
Omos: 4.8 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 3.6, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 2.8)

Women:

Mickie James: 8.7 (Look/Presence 9.0, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 9.0)
Becky Lynch: 8.7 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 9.5, Mic Skills 8.6)
BL: 8.4 (8.3, 7.8, 9.2, 8.3)
Sasha Banks: 8.4 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.2)
Bayley: 8.3 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 8.6, Charisma 8.5, Mic Skills 7.9)
Trish Stratus: 8.2 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 7.3, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.5)
Alexa Bliss: 8.2 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 9.0)
Gail Kim: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 7.1)
SB: 8.1 (8.5, 8.6, 8.4, 6.9)
TS: 8.1 (9.2, 7.2, 8.5, 7.4)

Jamie Hayter: 8.0 (Look/Presence 9.2, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 7.0)
Britt Baker: 8.0 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 8.6)
GK: 8.0 (8.7, 8.6, 7.6, 6.9)
Charlotte Flair: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.6, In-Ring Ability 8.5, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 7.1)
Bianca Belair: 7.8 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 6.2)
AJ Lee: 7.8 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 6.9, Charisma 8.5, Mic Skills 8.3)
Lita: 7.8 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 8.5, Mic Skills 6.2)
AJL: 7.7 (7.4, 6.8, 8.3, 8.3)
Rhea Ripley: 7.7 (Look/Presence 9.0, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 5.9)
CF: 7.6 (8.3, 8.1, 7.2, 6.8)
L: 7.6 (8.9, 7.0, 8.3, 6.0)

Kris Statlander: 7.5 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 7.4, Mic Skills 6.3)
AB: 7.5 (7.6, 6.1, 8.1, 8.2)
Sonya Deville: 7.5 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 7.3, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.3)
Lacey Evans: 7.4 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 6.1, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 7.6)
Toni Storm: 7.4 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.0)
Asuka: 7.4 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 4.3)
Thunder Rosa: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 6.0)
KS: 7.3 (8.1, 7.8, 7.2, 6.1)
BB: 7.3 (8.5, 7.8, 7.1, 5.8)

Zelina Vega: 7.2 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 6.1, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 8.3)
Liv Morgan: 7.1 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 6.8, Charisma 7.4, Mic Skills 6.0)
Mandy Rose: 7.0 (Look/Presence 9.0, In-Ring Ability 6.2, Charisma 6.7, Mic Skills 6.2)
Shayna Baszler: 7.0 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.7, Mic Skills 6.1)
LM: 6.8 (7.9, 6.5, 7.0, 5.7)
TR: 6.8 (7.4, 7.3, 6.9, 5.5)
TS: 6.7 (8.1, 7.2, 6.2, 5.4)
ZV: 6.7 (6.5, 5.7, 6.8, 7.8)

Eve Torres: 6.7 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 5.9, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.8)
ET: 6.5 (8.3, 5.8, 6.3, 5.6)
Ronda Rousey: 6.2 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 3.7)
RR: 6.0 (7.7, 6.7, 5.8, 3.6)

Today we will rate Jade Cargill since she also won the previous poll. This is your turn to vote. Make sure to keep up!

Please set each quality in this order (Look/Presence, In-Ring Ability, Charisma, Mic Skills), so it'll be easier to count your votes :)

NOTE: I'm willing to count late votes from my 2022 threads throughout this year. HOWEVER, please try not to do it too often because I'm REALLY not particularly fond of counting late votes in my free time; ESPECIALLY from June onwards since my series really begin to pick up in the 2nd half of the year. I'll probably be more forgiving for the 1st half of this year though. Plus, please do NOT spam my older rating threads all at once too. Anyway, my rankings are based off the MOST UPDATED standings. The MORE votes that are included to ALL of this, the MORE accurate the results will be. PLEASE MAKE SURE TO VOTE ON MY POLLS TOO :D

@Toxicoholic
 

DammitC

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,660
Points
113
Age
27
Jade Cargill:

Look/Presence: 10/10

In-Ring Ability: 6/10

Charisma: 7.5/10

Mic Skills: 6.5/10
 

Finishline

Drop the Mike
Joined
Sep 21, 2022
Messages
1,263
Reaction score
670
Points
113
Age
26
Location
North Carolina
Website
open.spotify.com
Favorite Wrestler
adamcole
Favorite Wrestler
chrisjericho
Favorite Wrestler
edge
Favorite Wrestler
sethrollins
I won't lie, I am not the biggest Jade Cargill fan. However, she's shown tremendous growth since her debut tag match with Shaq. I mean, a long way with her presentation. She hasn't been challenged in the ring, so not much to say there.

Look/Presence: 9/10
In-Ring Ability: 3/10
Charisma: 7/10
Mic Skills: 5/10
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitC

TeaDrinkingLimey

“Glass? Who gives a shit about glass?”
Joined
May 28, 2020
Messages
711
Reaction score
448
Points
63
Location
England
Favorite Wrestler
therock
Favorite Wrestler
stonecold
Favorite Wrestler
kurtangle
Favorite Wrestler
edge
Favorite Wrestler
cmpunk
Favorite Wrestler
danielbryan
Favorite Sports Team
53tBXAk

Kim Jong Umb

Big D Energy
Joined
Jun 10, 2019
Messages
83,853
Reaction score
14,009
Points
238
Age
31
Location
Buffalo
Favorite Wrestler
dJvrW4y
Favorite Wrestler
iHVgAJe
Favorite Wrestler
eIHNFff
Favorite Wrestler
6SLLEQr
Favorite Wrestler
flCHARR
Favorite Wrestler
hasWyGM
Favorite Sports Team
buffalosabres
Favorite Sports Team
3lUNnUV
Favorite Sports Team
K12LIMS
Favorite Sports Team
T5Zw0Si
10
8
7.5
6
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitC

Y2Jayne

2 levels above, 2 steps ahead
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
13,987
Reaction score
9,185
Points
113
Location
Toxic Lounge
Favorite Wrestler
chrisjericho2
Favorite Wrestler
DeSDzbM
Favorite Wrestler
9nCExBd
Favorite Wrestler
LDuO6dG
Favorite Wrestler
LBaYVuW
Favorite Wrestler
ToxicA
Look/Presence: 10/10

In-Ring Ability: 6.5/10

Charisma: 9/10

Mic Skills: 7.5/10
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitC

RDK

All glory to God
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
19,491
Reaction score
3,838
Points
113
Age
31
Location
Massachusetts
Favorite Wrestler
wadebarrett
Favorite Sports Team
eZIPN8K
Jade Cargill:

Look/Presence: 10/10

In-Ring Ability: 8/10

Charisma: 10/10

Mic Skills: 10/10
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitC

Chris

Dreams are Endless
Joined
Dec 23, 2011
Messages
383,775
Reaction score
155,570
Points
128
Age
28
Location
Texas
Favorite Wrestler
tLCb5kv
Favorite Wrestler
OEndG4L
Favorite Wrestler
ArsUxsj
Favorite Wrestler
mrperfect2
Favorite Wrestler
eelOIL6
Favorite Wrestler
BryanDanielson1
Favorite Sports Team
sfa
Favorite Sports Team
dallascowboys
Favorite Sports Team
sanantoniospurs
Favorite Sports Team
texasrangers
10
6
10
8
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitC