Is CM Punk really such a darling? From the threads I've seen, he seems more hated than loved. Not just around here, either. I stumbled across a place called wrestlingforum the other day and they had a thread about Punk's role at MiTB. Basically they were all hoping he'd get F-5ed off a ladder through a flaming table studded with tacks and wrapped in barbed wire and hopefully killed and put out of our collective misery.
Seriously, I think Bryan would have to be the number 1 darling. Bryan is almost universally loved. I don't think there's anyone who doesn't love the little guy.
Second would have to be Ziggler. He has almost no haters, just love. Not as much love as Bryan, but still plenty.
Third, Y2J. Part timer, but still very well loved.
Forth, Ambrose. Some people are meh toward him, but not many. Most of his fans would blow him if they could.
Fifth, Punk. Large amount of fans, but the real smarks mostly hate him for whatever odd reason.
I don't really watch TNA, so I can't comment on them. But TNA isn't really the same league as WWE, so...