I suppose its possible if they janned the cop N1 but if they did oh well, shrug, good game. I doubt this place would lynch to confirm results and I doubt we have the room anyway. They've gotten the SK gone so they don't really have to worry about an inadvertent flip and should be able to coast on the cop claim. So if Rug was the cop and they janned him N1, oh well.
Why would I go for my scummate instead of the SK then when I had already said I copped both in thread and others were going Barry first?
This plan would involve you saying a scummate is scum in the thread as a bus so I don't see why it would matter what order you go for them in.
in any case chris is not going anywhere soon unless he's shot so this conversation is likely unneeded currently imo
Is there a reason I should assume your play is always what's most beneficial to you, or that you make the optimal play at all times? Is it not possible that the remaining scum have a way of ensuring none of them are killed by the SK? Like roleblocking him if they fear he will shoot scum, or some other role to protect who they fear he may shoot? Like, its all wifom.
I find it more interesting that you seem keenly interested in defending what was a throwaway, unpushed thought that felt the scenario was unlikely and unlucky if it had happened.