Prison Break Mafia Game Thread

[Rugrat]

here be my leans

1. Chris - level headed, asking good questions and active - lines up with my meta-knowledge of a town Chris
2. Nom - flavourgate and an overall weird performance from Nom has me questioning him, would be happy to lynch today if that's the general direction. The switch from "just lynch me then" to now begging to survive is it's almost as if he wants to be lynched.
3. Jeff - as prev, didn't quite like the Jeff/Tweet exchange, felt forced. Jeff grew into the game and it felt like a more confidence and driven Jeff which I'd associate with a town Jeff. The baity posts at me had me slowly reverse up from the town lean and wonder some WIFOM shit. The whole Tweet direction made me realise that his post did look more opportunistic than Tweets did on Junk. People have discussed Jeffs scum meta but I think it depends on his team - a weaker team where Jeff can lead and I think that translates a lot better into the thread than Jeff with a stronger team where he's not necessarily the loudest voice. Probably town, I'm conspiracy theorying that he could not be.
4. Tweet - not a great entrance, hasn't really offered a lot and his disappearing act after Pez directed some q's at him
7. Odo - More than likely town I think but if Junk is scum, I'd like to look here.
8. Junk - inconsistent with a lot of contradictions, I still don't buy the opening reaction post and her case and confidence on Tweet feels lacklustre. Main basis is that Tweet looked opportunistic by joining the Junk wagon.
11. Magic - something feels off, lacking the commanding town meta Magic has brought in recent games (when he actually posts ofc) and the fact he hasn't shit on anyone for the amount of claims we've had D1 is a pretty big sign for me lol considering the previous tantrums we've seen over this.
19. Pez - comfortable, active, pushing directions and looks happy to be at the forefront of interactions and questioning. Probs my strongest town read
20. Poyser - he brought up a few points earlier that actually matched my own and points I'd already brought up in the thread. Have a lean

vote PHEN0M

Why did you vote Phen0m? You suggested Jeff and Tweet were being forced (loose implication of bussing). And on this very page Junk who is your number 1 scum read voted Phen0m? seems odd

 

[Canadian Dragon]

ill be back, ill wait for more concrete reads to come in and reassess, myself.

 

[Tweet]

I had scum on day one again and you just let him get away??

The only context in which you "had scum" is you probably had scum laughing at you for being so sure about me. If you're town that is.

 

[Showtime]

no idea, I'd guess any characters who came after the first season.



You initially posited that you didn't like Phenom's play. It wasn't until Odo had raised suspicion on him that you voted him, why?

i honestly have no idea if this timeline is accurate lol.

i voted tweet because some people were pushing it and wanted to see where it would go/tweet's reaction/who jumped on, etc. he then claimed and i got bored and went with my own direction. odo's suspicion had nothing to do with my vote on phen0m.

 

[Rugrat]

I've read 89% of the thread now

 

[Showtime]

Yes to both.



He did. He voted Tweet.



Vig candidate for mine is TKOK - eliminates the POE that he'll ultimately come down to and can provide some good reads. Tweet as well.

what reads can you get from a tkok flip?

 

[Evans]

Why did you vote Phen0m? You suggested Jeff and Tweet were being forced (loose implication of bussing). And on this very page Junk who is your number 1 scum read voted Phen0m? seems odd

I had dialled back on Jeff/Tweet to pursue other options as I was going down a tunnel and it felt pointless harping on about it rather than letting play go on and returning to it later.

At the time I voted Phenom, Junk was heavily pushing Tweet.

 

[Showtime]

Phen0m (11) - Magic, Odo, Alco, Tweet, Doddsy, Lethal, Jeff, Chris, Poyser, EV

My current reads thus far. Not... ideal tbh. Maybe I need to start reading back on some of these fellas to garner a read.

what's your read on doddsy?

 

[Rugrat]

1. Chris
3. Jeff
4. Tweet
5. Ace
6. Barry
7. Odo
8. Junk
9. Ev
10. Mikey
11. Magic
12. Doddsy
13. Lethal
14. Alco
15. Big Man
16. Brutus
17. TKOK
18. Chimp
19. Pez
20. Poyser

I haven't noticed much of Chris really. He's the player that I know the least of "quite frankly".

Tweet hasn't seemed especially anything, but Big Man raised some interesting points on him.

Ace had a good point to read Evans town on, in that he had pushed all three suspects for a lynch which would draw attention to him. To further add to his position, there's a fair chance that one of the three is scum - so he was eager for a scum lynch. I think if I'm scum I'd say he was wagon hopping, so I think if Ace is looking to read people town, he is probably town himself.

Barry hasn't offered much other than fairly banal statements. I do remember him being obnoxiously banal in Mr Robot Mafia as scum, so he's someone to watch out for.

Odo had a fine initial case on Phenom. Phenom really didn't help himself with WIFOM which is more likely to bait users further into lynching them.

Magic has been pretty much a non-factor. He claims to enjoy being town more than non-town though. I did agree largely with his read list tbf to him, and it was a good point on Mikey that saved me having to bring it up myself.

Doddsy hasn't offered much, which doesn't really make him town or scum as he does tend to dip in and out of thread as town, while often being aggressive as scum (thoughh he can be aggressive as town). His play with the Hated Townie is lousy, VIG SHOULD LOOK HERE

I don't really like Lethal's case on TKOK. I'm fairly sure Lethal has been boned by TKOK as town then it's eh. Considering that he does tunnel lesser players like Sky and Chimp, it kinda suggests an easy segue.

Haven't noticed Alco.

Big Man seems town, but he's a good player. I agree with his points and reads on Lethal and Evans so I'd be inclined to read him town, but he's still not offered loads though.

Brutus is someone I'm also unsure on how to form reads on.

TKOK is a token lynch.

Poyser has offered little. Tbf trolling aside, it wouldn't have been the worst idea to ramp the pressure up on him.

 

[Showtime]

the fact he could have proven is role and none seemed to care, also weird just sayin (PHENOM)

ima be 100% fair jeff

proving your role means fuck all lol

as a host youre meant to give scum provable roles. not ones that would confirm them, but ones that would get them caught. it doesnt really mean much(as in no one should have doubted neighbourizer was his actual role, it's just if there's a bonus mafia perk to it).

 

[Showtime]

@Rugrat im confused by you not realizing the phen0m stuff. like did you miss it and how? odo even suggested im scum with tweet because my push on phen0m made it seem like a diversion wagon. it's not on just any single point in the thread.

 

[Showtime]

1. Chris
3. Jeff
4. Tweet
5. Ace = NULL
6. Barry
7. Odo
8. Junk
9. Ev
10. Mikey = NULL
11. Magic
12. Doddsy
13. Lethal
14. Alco
15. Big Man
16. Brutus
17. TKOK
18. Chimp Rugrat = NULL
19. Pez
20. Poyser

Nulls ~ I just don't remember much of value from Ace to help me with a read (aside from his reads list that he provided for Poyser and notes). Mikey hasn't done much either to make himself noticed.

Yellows ~ I never trust Barry, and he's hard to read for mine. Doddsy has the hated claim, and last time he claimed that (WWF iirc) he was hated scum, and after Heroes, I'll be very vigilant of him this time around. Brutus is always a suspect in my mind due to his low post count.

Oranges ~ I've already provided my suss of TKOK, and Tweet still doesn't look great given his claiming and play around it, in spite of his post answering my question as for his motivation of his actions.

Solid blues ~ Jeff doesn't go that ham on someone if he's scum, he wants to shy attention away from himself. Odo is in an absolute purple patch, and whilst wrong on N0M, I have faith in him once more. Pez is making too much sense in his posts, and Poyser proved his claim and I like his play to date

Light blues ~ I like what they're bringing to the table, and I'm forming ideas on them

wait why do you have me as town?

 

[Pez]

Ignored again.

 

[Rugrat]

@Rugrat im confused by you not realizing the phen0m stuff. like did you miss it and how? odo even suggested im scum with tweet because my push on phen0m made it seem like a diversion wagon. it's not on just any single point in the thread.

I haven't missed anything. I was just wondering why you didn't push Phenom until Odo mentioned it as you mentioned being suspicious of Phenom at a formative part of the thread but not until later did you act upon it.

 

[Showtime]

An 11 person wagon has scum on?!?!?!?!

This reeks of TMI

I'm pretty sure what Rugrat is saying to barry there is


NO SHIT. like fucking duh there's likely to be scum on an 11 man wagon on d1. MATH!

gonna point out that barry also had a list of 5 people he said likely has at least 1 scum on it. his play isn't exactly narrowing anything down and playing the odds is easy enough. town barry from what i remember typically has more bite in following what he thinks is right or at least being more vocal about it even if he decides to defer.