PPV2: Alpha Dog- -PHENOM- (c) vs. Andrew vs. BDC vs. Doink

[Andy]

-PHENOM-'s (c) Entry

Andrew's Entry

Doink's Entry

BDC's Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Tuesday June 5, 2012 at 10 P.M. (Central Time)
Good luck!​

 

[Andrew]

Can't vote myself so I am going to vote Doink here.

His work was good.

 

[Doink]

Can't vote myself so going Andrew. I like the way he put the musical symbols effect in the text is brilliant but I think there is a bit too much empty space in the background

Phenom, I almost put your name out and it was a very good piece however the two Sin Caras are just weird for me. There is no border which is a major turnoff for me and the bits with Zigglers and Punks arms into that white thing is weird. Anywhere is spelt wrong and I don't like the position of the renders

1. Andrew
2. -PHENOM-

 

[The Hoov]

I like them all but I love the concept of Andrew's. The music symbols, as Doink says, is a nice touch.

 

[Defiant]

Voting for Doink. The colours, splatter, effects, lighting and text are all very solid. Nice work.

Phenom, this is also really good work and I like how no space is left unused. Your work tends to look much more professional when you step away from sigs. I don't have any criticisms here and deciding on my vote was tough, but Doink gets it only because of how much he really stepped it up for this one and how visible his improvement is here.

Andrew, yours is consistent in colouring and theme, but next to the others it just looks plain. Perhaps a bit of lighting would've brought this out more. Its not a bad piece, it just doesn't look "complete".

 

[Lub]

I'm voting for Doink. I just like his piece best. Maybe the render could flow better with the background, but it's really good piece. From the last time I saw your work, you've improved a lot bro and this is example of your improvement.

 

[Heisenberg]

Going with Andrew here. Like the music symbols.

 

[Andy]

BDC's entry has just been added on account of the fact that this is a title match. If you would like to change your vote to his entry, feel free.

 

[!PHENOM!]

Doink gets my Vote: not unique work just same work as last time you beat me with that type of banner....only weak point will be texts....and the overall collaboration of effects and render is nice....

Andrew: i think you did some quick job or rushed....the empty space in banner kills it....i only love the texts here but it didn't get the job done..

BDC:the only BG may the weakest point here...unless it's nice effort but you need some more improvements.....keep it up

 

[Andy]

The battle is now closed.
Doink (4) def. Andrew (3), -PHENOM- (0), & BDC (0)
Congratulations to Doink for becoming the second ALPHA DOG CHAMP!