Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Showtime]

big man i feel like you're just not the hider.

you couldn't realistically say you hid behind ant either be able to explain 1) not dying behind them as they're likely scum 2) explaining why scum didn't shoot there.

like if you hid behind odo and announced it, if odo is town they're probably going to shoot odo there as they get a 2 for 1 on good players.

if you legitimately hid behind sky and she flips scum you're then both fucked.

now you can also suggest using your role has a protection role instead of having to hide someone on another night.

At the risk of being a fucking Simpson I believe Phenom over Big Man.

they could also both be scum.

 

[Big Man]

That's actually fair. This whole thing is doing my head in.

Wait, unless you feared Sky flipping scum?

But why pick her then? Excuse me, I'm just thinking out loud.

I would’ve just claimed I was 1-shot and hider not drop a hint at all or just say what I’m saying now about trying to bait scum into killing sky, not admit I LIED about my whole claim lmao.

 

[Smart Marx]

I guess the scum motivation for Big Man to fuck with his claim is to ensure Sky remains in PoE.

It would have to be or to remove a link in case the SK or CP kills Sky.

 

[Big Man]

big man i feel like you're just not the hider.

you couldn't realistically say you hid behind ant either be able to explain 1) not dying behind them as they're likely scum 2) explaining why scum didn't shoot there.

like if you hid behind odo and announced it, if odo is town they're probably going to shoot odo there as they get a 2 for 1 on good players.

if you legitimately hid behind sky and she flips scum you're then both fucked.

now you can also suggest using your role has a protection role instead of having to hide someone on another night.



they could also both be scum.

I have no idea what you’re saying

 

[Showtime]

cp were you told that you were blocked? do you know if you would be told if you were blocked?

 

[CraigPelton]

they could also both be scum.

maybe but like I actually have a town read on phenom lmao

 

[PHEN0M]

I just want credit when big man flips Jailkeeper.

 

[CraigPelton]

cp were you told that you were blocked? do you know if you would be told if you were blocked?

I have not been told. I'll ask

 

[Rugrat]

Idk where his Odo example comes from which is my main issue

 

[Showtime]

I have no idea what you’re saying

if you hid behind sky and sky goes on to flip scum, it would also confirm you as scum ya? because otherwise you would have died hiding behind her.

that means the motivation to change your claim is so you dont both get caught together. also you can now use your role as a "protection" role.

it just sounds like a jailkeeper.

 

[Smart Marx]

I just want credit when big man flips Jailkeeper.

Jailed CP and then distanced from Sky?

 

[CraigPelton]

Wonder who Lethal watched!

 

[Smart Marx]

Some info would be very helpful about now.

 

[Showtime]

Idk where his Odo example comes from which is my main issue

that was a hypothetical if he offered to hide behind odo at night instead of sky, which he didnt end up doing. it doesn't work because if they're both town then scum would realistically shoot them.

if he says he hid behind sky and we lynch her anyways then we get a 2 for 1(because quite frankly his info wouldn't be the decided at this stage).

 

[Odo]

What an extremely excellent time to start a pivotal phase