Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

The only way he can prove his role is by dying tonight.

"Prove" is a strong word, but without a soft we don't even know whom he's hiding behind.

So when he doesn't die he'll have to clear someone. If his targets seems like a weird choice we can scrutinize it, yeah?

 

[Rugrat]

What your thoughts on the rest of my reads? Your entire rant here seems to placed on the fact I'm reading you scum.

Which no one likes to be read scum, but how about thoughts on the rest of my reads. I'm happy to hear your opinions on them.

Just in case I'm wrong about you and just in case I'm not.

Other people have read me scum this game, my issue is clearly that you've listed me scum because you disliked one of my 186 posts.

I said your reason on Big Man wasn't very good, in any circumstance.

There's no point engaging on your reads when you haven't caught up. I've given my thoughts in any circumstance.

 

[Smart Marx]

I said your reason on Big Man wasn't very good, in any circumstance.

You seriously don't think we critique his hidee choices?

 

[Rugrat]

"Prove" is a strong word, but without a soft we don't even know whom he's hiding behind.

So when he doesn't die he'll have to clear someone. If his targets seems like a weird choice we can scrutinize it, yeah?

He isn't going to soft it, he's going to come out and say it - because scum know he is the hider so can just as easily pick up the hint. If he hides behind scum, he will die. If he hides behind town, scum will kill his target and he will also die.

 

[Smart Marx]

Other people have read me scum this game, my issue is clearly that you've listed me scum because you disliked one of my 186 posts.

Sometimes you just get a feeling.

There's no point engaging on your reads when you haven't caught up. I've given my thoughts in any circumstance.

Well then. I guess we're done here.

 

[Big Man]

so big man has left like no clues on who he is hiding behind?

 

[Rugrat]

FYI you brought up "proving" at this juncture, the only way he can prove himself is by dying. Personally, I don't think he's scum, so don’t need to see him prove his role

 

[Big Man]

@Rugrat

assuming I were to hide tonight would you say you know who I’m hiding behind or do I need to be clearer?

 

[Rugrat]

@Rugrat

assuming I were to hide tonight would you say you know who I’m hiding behind or do I need to be clearer?

idk who you’re hiding behind, no. But either say no hint or say it outright

 

[Doddsy]

why me? what do you think of Phenom

I don't think you've been playing your town game so far, you're far more in and trying to box people in for a mislynch.

Phenom I think is fine, I said so earlier. It might come down to PoE that we've already had the BG flip, in which case he might just be a seraph for the GF though. Why I was asking if he was set to a character or if he could pick who he was on

 

[Rugrat]

I think I've worked out who you're hiding behind, but so will scum.

 

[Big Man]

fair enough. skybox.

 

[Doddsy]

I don't really get the Sky scum reads tbh, maybe we'll know more tomorrow.

This is the hint then?

 

[Rugrat]

I don't think you've been playing your town game so far, you're far more in and trying to box people in for a mislynch.

Phenom I think is fine, I said so earlier. It might come down to PoE that we've already had the BG flip, in which case he might just be a seraph for the GF though. Why I was asking if he was set to a character or if he could pick who he was on

Eh at this ambiguity. What is my usual town game? I'd say I'm one of the last people here to have a "usual game".

The aim of the game is to box people in. It's the best way to get a read of people.

 

[Smart Marx]

Taking Sky out of POE?