Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Rugrat]

Another thing I wanna point out is there's no way all of Magic, Odo, CP and Big Man are town. If they all were we wouldn't have this much trouble catching even one scum.

well Big Man has “confirmed” CP, so it’s one of Magic, Odo and Big Man. Odo is the day vig and Big Man has an investigative roles

 

[Lethal]

What do you mean by suspicious kill choice, Haza?

He was ripe for the lynching, or a claim at worst.

Is it because you jailkept me n1?

Absolutely

 

[Tweet]

well Big Man has “confirmed” CP, so it’s one of Magic, Odo and Big Man. Odo is the day vig and Big Man has an investigative roles

Ye unless Big Man is scum CP is clear, I think Odo is scum and Magic also could be. He's been posting a lot but it feels like nothing really came from those posts, no wagons, no cases, few clears. Could be wrong on that, would have to reread and probably will once I get off work like 7 hours from now.

 

[Odo]

Ye unless Big Man is scum CP is clear, I think Odo is scum and Magic also could be.

Ignoring the part about me, this is awful

- Big Man and CPs alignments arent linked like that

- We dont know what means Big Man 'cleared' CP through, so I dont really get why youre so happy to accept this at face value?

 

[Lethal]

I really want to say something but I can't yet

 

[Rugrat]

Ignoring the part about me, this is awful

- Big Man and CPs alignments arent linked like that

- We dont know what means Big Man 'cleared' CP through, so I dont really get why youre so happy to accept this at face value?

Big Man has info CP is town, so I'm inclined to believe him. Why would you not?

 

[Odo]

Because I think Big Man is scum, and therefore dont trust anything he says?

 

[Sky]

I have the opposite reaction. I think less of Big Man because he's claiming to be clearing my scum read CP

 

[Rugrat]

Because I think Big Man is scum, and therefore dont trust anything he says?

It'd be a very naive gambit to tie the two of them like that

 

[Lethal]

I think more votes on Magic.

Jeff, I say Jeff, where you at man?

 

[Rugrat]

Vote Magic

 

[Tweet]

So what is your problem with me saying that unless Big Man is scum, CP is clear? I make no statement about Big Mans alignment in there.

Also if you think Big Man is scum, why aren't you pushing him?

 

[Odo]

What, you mean like the one we saw Phenom and Doddsy do 2 games ago?

May also be plausible deniability baked in if CP were investigation immune for example

Bottom line, scum read A ‘clearing’ scum read B doesn’t do anything for me, and I’m sceptical of anyone disagreeing there

again, I’ll ask why did big man even out the info? What was in it for him, given that CP wasn’t staring down the barrel?

 

[Tweet]

Unvote
vote Magic

Sure

 

[Odo]

So what is your problem with me saying that unless Big Man is scum, CP is clear? I make no statement about Big Mans alignment in there.

Also if you think Big Man is scum, why aren't you pushing him?

because it’s faulty on an obvious level - you don’t even know how he was cleared

and I thought it was obvious that I am pushing him, so I don’t really know what you’re talking about