Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Odo]

JOAT or cop?

 

[PHEN0M]

That’s a fun, elongated way of claiming cop.

Vote: Doddsy

 

[PHEN0M]

I’ll saunter back shortly, any pertinent info that’s pressing i should know?

 

[Rugrat]

this @Showtime guy suggesting I’m scum for following a town read saying what’s below on someone I wasn’t reading town.

I really want to say something but I can't yet

I think more votes on Magic.

Jeff, I say Jeff, where you at man?

 

[Showtime]

kk ima do this as quickly as possible but look at barry's posts and reads:

These motherfuckers out here stealing my Komi-san emoji.

Why don't you go ahead and steal while you're at it, fuckers.

Also Smark's town.

smark is town.

page 4, post 46. this is important for later.

Yeah no, I feel fairly confident on Smark being town again this round.

high confidence. doesn't say why at any point, just high confidence.

and before anyone asks "barry isn't one to have reasons", ya typically but when he's so sure and when it's in regards to smark he typically does. it's going to be based on meta so he could have specified why.

What is there to gain from lynching him?

You didn't answer my question.

So you just want him to claim?

this all looks like fake shit to me.

first of all my push on brad was before he posted, which was well known, and yet his first assumption was i was trying to lynch him. that doesn't really make sense.

when i specify it isn't for a lynch he then talks as if it's for a claim.

this all seems needless. this isn't the crux of my issue with barry or why i think he's scum, but i just thought this interaction was lacking. i do think it's weird he was calling me out but not trying to call me scummy though or even vote me considering he disagreed with what i was doing and thought i was trying to lynch someone who hadn't posted yet.

60/40

Smark could fake claim Miller and fuck off to god know's where and we'd just let him, which is why play is *particularly* important with Smark, not just claim.

if play is so important with smark and you think he could be faking miller, giving him such a sure-fire town read on post 46 seems a bit careless, no? like i dont really doubt miller claims, but if barry is actually paranoid about them just giving them a town read almost immediately anyways seems pointless.

(smark/barry have this love affair shit anyways so i could see barry buddying smark as scum, not necessarily in a manipulative manner just because he would feel safe in those interactions)

Or so you say.

@Undeniable

thoughts on barry now?

to be continued....ON THE NEXT EPISODE OF RECYCLED BALLS MULTI-QUOTE.

 

[Odo]

You’re featuring quite high on a lot of players shit lists

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Magic's town.

Also straight one, Odo.

 

[PHEN0M]

Hey Magic, guy just claimed cop. Good effort.

 

[Odo]

If Barry is claiming cop and Doddsy flips scum, that raises questions on big man

 

[PHEN0M]

You’re featuring quite high on a lot of players shit lists

Is this at me? That’s unfortunate if so, I’m happy to hear why.

 

[Odo]

Anyway, vote Doddsy

 

[Big Man]

My hypothetical was that if Magic and Bradatar were scum together, Magic would not have gone after Bradatar like that. Since Magic did go after Bradatar, the implication then is that they cannot be scum together.

I also knew Bradatar(me) was town. Then I made a brainfart by jumping to the conclusion since I was town and I know both me and Magic can't be scum together, Magic msut be town.

I can give it in standard form.

1-Magic and Bradatar cannot be scum together
2-Bradatar is town.
Therefore,
3-Magic is town.

I can't explain why I jumped from 1 and 2 to 3. Its just a brainfart and I didn't realize it until I was well deep into defending what I was saying.

But I also don't understand why me talking about a hypothetical means that I mist be scum. I am hypothetically talking abot if Magic and Bradatar are scum together and arguing they cannot be scum together. How does that equuate to me being scum? Its a hypothetical for a reason. In fact, the hypothetical only works on the assumption that I am town as shown by 2.

no it only works if you/brad is scum lol. the only way you could say magic is town off that is if brad flipped scum. and if you knew you replaced in for Brad, why on earth would you come up with a hypothetical of them both being scum (you didn't even preface it as a hypothethical btw you just straight up said magic is definetely town) when you already KNOW one of them is town?

 

[Odo]

Is this at me? That’s unfortunate if so, I’m happy to hear why.

not particularly on mine as it stands

 

[Odo]

Why are all these long time absent players suddenly rolling in lmao

 

[Odo]

hey big man

how did you clear cp?