Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Showtime]

great game and setup and hosting job jeff. thanks for the game.

congratulations to the winners on an excellent performance

don't tag me for future games. I have no desire to do this to myself anymore.

but why


twas a game.

 

[Smart Marx]

great game and setup and hosting job jeff. thanks for the game.

congratulations to the winners on an excellent performance

don't tag me for future games. I have no desire to do this to myself anymore.

I didn't mean to hurt you. Don't leave us.

 

[Poyser]

Thank you for teaching us this important lesson about miller fakes by the way

why the fuck did Poyser sign off on that

I had no idea what he was doing with fakes lol

but also I probably wouldn’t have tried to talk him out of it anyway

 

[Odo]

Lol, why would you

 

[Poyser]

Yes, and that was bad by Poyser, see above for why

Nah otherwise scum would’ve been completely fucked because they had no roles that could actually be claimed other than miller and vt lol, I gave them a couple fringe roles that they could claim (which still weren’t good claims) just to give a bit of flexibility

also loads of people give fake roles if scum don’t already have roles they can claim lol, not sure where this came from

 

[Smart Marx]

Nah otherwise scum would’ve been completely fucked because they had no roles that could actually be claimed other than miller and vt lol, I gave them a couple fringe roles that they could claim (which still weren’t good claims) just to give a bit of flexibility

also loads of people give fake roles if scum don’t already have roles they can claim lol, not sure where this came from

I'm confused by this as well. I've played so many games with full fakes. I only started giving them after being talked into it.

 

[Poyser]

Fwiw Tho I do agree with scum actually having roles they can claim being infinitely better

 

[Smart Marx]

Fwiw Tho I do agree with scum actually having roles they can claim being infinitely better

I've done that as well. Though, I occasionally still get scum wanting a role that isn't theirs.

That's also because Tracker/watchers etc become so poeable now.

 

[Poyser]

But that tends to mean most scum members have multiple roles which can make them more powerful as well and if you’re giving scum a claimable role then it’s fair to say they know those roles aren’t in the game and probably nothing too similar or whatever so that problem of them knowing what’s not in the game is gonna exist regardless of what happens. Only way to stop that is to ban role claiming

 

[Poyser]

Congrats to the scum team by the way, great performance

was legit in fucking stitches when I realised phenom posting ‘you can take those actions as final jeff’ was a legit slip. That post in the scum qt

 

[Doddsy]

I blame Chimp for making that a seamless joke

 

[Odo]

Fwiw Tho I do agree with scum actually having roles they can claim being infinitely better

The mix for me is some scum get claimable shit, and some have to fake

It shouldnt be a case where all members of a team have a claimable role lined up from the first post. Town should be rewarded for finding scum quickly

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Oh wow the game ended without me

 

[Rugrat]

Well played scum! Thanks for the game, Jeff.

 

[Rugrat]

There have been enough games where scum have full fakes

but giving them a miller fake is handing them a win