Not going to really go in depth on it but I've caught up on One Piece . . .
I've been pretty into Hunter X Hunter recently (clearly) so my recommendation would be to start watching that (only saw three of Magi, I only watch once a week like most of the animes I'm currently watching). Not sure how much you've seen but I just finished up the Hunter Exam arc and will likely blow through the rest of the series in a month or less. Hunter X Hunter only has 108 episodes out at the moment if I recall correctly, that's nothing compared to One Piece and once I started marathoning it, it didn't take me too long to catch up (I mean, I averaged about twenty episodes a day at one point). The first phase of the Exam isn't really that interesting except for Hisoka's bits (Hisoka has easily became one of my favorite villains). The second part I tolerated because it was only one episode long but after that the show starts getting great. The third phase was probably my favorite overall but the Hisoka parts in the fourth are the moments in those two exams and most of the fifth, which I really liked and had one part that was excellent.
Yeah, Brotherhood is fantastic (though I have my problems with the early episodes since I saw the original series first [and the content that was repeated in both was done so much better in the original]). I'd only put a few select animes over Brotherhood, so you've started with one of the best ones out there.
^This opening > all openings. Doesn't even show the best part, which is that the seamlessly incorporate recaps into the opening in the later episodes (I think maybe all of them except two do this). Brotherhood's had great animation and some good tracks but I love this track much more than any of the openings in anime and Baccano!'s opening is more distinctive than any of Brotherhood's. Durarara!! has similar style openings but they aren't as good. Also, on the chance you haven't watched Baccano!, I'd highly recommend giving the dub a chance. Much like Cowboy Bebop, it's universally agreed to be better dubbed (with the rare exception of course).
Ignoring the most recent chapter which was just okay, I think the last batch of chapters have been the best chapters in One Piece so far. I mean, it's not even a surprise that Sabo's alive and a revolutionary but I would've never thought that he'd be revealed this early (which when I think about it, is the really amazing thing since due to Ace's DF being on the line this is the most viable time for him to appear but with how jam-packed the arc the thought never occurred to me). Dressrosa is really shaping up to be the series best arc, Sabo & Koala (who I loved in Fisher Tiger's backstory so I marked for her aswell) showed up, Fujitora is a total badass, Doflamingo tops even Crocodile in manipulative bastardness, Law's existence the Dwarves/Toys raising up for resistance (along with Usoland's crew), the involvement of three Yonko (whether direct or indirect), the tournament has holstered plenty of characters with either interesting abilities (the King Punch) or fun personalities (Bartolomeo) (side note: Rebecca is really bland and she so isn't joining the crew), and most importantly of all, it seems that my man Sanji might finally get lucky what with this Viola chick and all.
I really need to get to watching other anime's like Hunter X Hunter, Beezlebub, Magi, ect.
I'm just reading One Piece, Naruto and Fairy Tail.
Speaking of One Piece, I enjoyed the most recent episode too.
I've been pretty into Hunter X Hunter recently (clearly) so my recommendation would be to start watching that (only saw three of Magi, I only watch once a week like most of the animes I'm currently watching). Not sure how much you've seen but I just finished up the Hunter Exam arc and will likely blow through the rest of the series in a month or less. Hunter X Hunter only has 108 episodes out at the moment if I recall correctly, that's nothing compared to One Piece and once I started marathoning it, it didn't take me too long to catch up (I mean, I averaged about twenty episodes a day at one point). The first phase of the Exam isn't really that interesting except for Hisoka's bits (Hisoka has easily became one of my favorite villains). The second part I tolerated because it was only one episode long but after that the show starts getting great. The third phase was probably my favorite overall but the Hisoka parts in the fourth are the moments in those two exams and most of the fifth, which I really liked and had one part that was excellent.
It was Brotherhood. Only just starting to get into anime and randomly bought it off an amazon recommendation so glad I did was funny, entertaining, had a good storyline and a quirky style that really had me interested from the start.
Yeah, Brotherhood is fantastic (though I have my problems with the early episodes since I saw the original series first [and the content that was repeated in both was done so much better in the original]). I'd only put a few select animes over Brotherhood, so you've started with one of the best ones out there.
Don't forget those opening songs smurf! They're the best anime openings for a series of all time.
^This opening > all openings. Doesn't even show the best part, which is that the seamlessly incorporate recaps into the opening in the later episodes (I think maybe all of them except two do this). Brotherhood's had great animation and some good tracks but I love this track much more than any of the openings in anime and Baccano!'s opening is more distinctive than any of Brotherhood's. Durarara!! has similar style openings but they aren't as good. Also, on the chance you haven't watched Baccano!, I'd highly recommend giving the dub a chance. Much like Cowboy Bebop, it's universally agreed to be better dubbed (with the rare exception of course).