Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

I'm more annoyed at you not clearing me than anything Lethal what's done is done though, just have to give you the gears a LILTTLE BIT

 

[Smart Marx]

If I was Hel, why would I be asking someone if they could heal the guy I presumably poisoned?

Agreed, but I also don't think town should be alerting said poison to town's only shot at curing said poison.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Who's to say CP is still town and/or has his role? He didn't save TKOK and had the chance to do so

That's a fair point. I looked up reviver though at the time, and the most common one is to revive as VT. I'm guessing/hoping that is the case. I'm just not going to give any power into alignment changing roles in an ODO game. I'd legit eat my hat.

 

[Evans]

Yeah, I was curious about that since the character shared the scum alignment, but how does that increase your odds on Magic?

We don't know he IS that character. Just speculation based on his play or lack thereof.

Who mentioned Odo has used them before? I think I remember him using them in Ace.

The 5% increase is from reading back over Magics posts and his change in play.
It stinks to high heavens.

We don't know he is definitely that character no, but I'm pretty sure I've got him here.

 

[Smart Marx]

He's not town otherwise he'd be playing and giving us town reads and telling us we're idiots for lynching Flay when he was so sure that Flay was town earlier on in the thread. Look how he acted around the Haza lynch.

This is an excellent point tbf.

Agreed. It really doesn't feel like a town Magic. I'll be sad if he's straight scum, though. I still stand by that.

 

[Lethal]

Wasn't he dead when TKOK was poisoned though? And revived when TKOK died?

No. He was revived and TKOK was still alive. CP then came in with his "oh I forgot I'm alive" spiel.

I'm more annoyed at you not clearing me than anything Lethal what's done is done though, just have to give you the gears a LILTTLE BIT

I hit the desk when I saw night was over

 

[Ace]

Agreed, but I also don't think town should be alerting said poison to town's only shot at curing said poison.

Given Rugrat is poisoned I would disagree. During the night, I agree alerting would have been bad.. Although we didn't know there was a poisoner then so that is irrelevant.

 

[Evans]

The reason I think he's more likely to be Surtr over Hel is that I can't see Magic eliminating Rugrat who's barely been here all game.

He'd poison Lethal, you or me and stink up someone else around that for the lynch.

 

[Lethal]

Although that's an excellent point re: reviving as VT, could explain why TKOK wasn't cured

 

[Ace]

No. He was revived and TKOK was still alive. CP then came in with his "oh I forgot I'm alive" spiel.

Oh, that's my bad.

I can understand my asking CP if he can heal Rugrat looking a bit weird then, fair play.

 

[Evans]

This is an excellent point tbf.

You know what to do

 

[Smart Marx]

Given Rugrat is poisoned I would disagree. During the night, I agree alerting would have been bad.. Although we didn't know there was a poisoner then so that is irrelevant.

You think CP wouldn't see Rugrat and just do it on his own?

I see your point about day, but still. Fishing always looks weird to me.

 

[Comrade Khan]

1. Ace
2. Evans
3. CP
4. Alco
5. Jeff
6. Lethal
7. Barry
8. Tweet
9. Smark
12. OMB
14. Magic v2
16. Doddsy
18. Rugrat
19. Big Man
21. Brutus

where i am currently. brutus read is based on his hinted role+ him seemingly paying attention. rugrat got poisoned so imma assume he's town unless he's the other indy somehow, and if he is, fuck him he's dying tonight anyway. CP im sayin is town based on his previous life, not going to entertain alignment switches until they are proven. EV/Smark obviously leading town. lethal still most likely town, i dont think he plays dumb forgetting to use his role as scum, he's better than that crap, so he probably just legit missed it.

that leaves the two indies in green

scum within: tweet, alco, big man, doddsy and OMB imo.

id obviously lean tweet first, then big man I guess? i havent hated alco and oddsys posts but they are good at blending in as scum so i have to realisitically put them in poe. OMB is a wildcard as always i guess


thoughts?

 

[Smart Marx]

Although that's an excellent point re: reviving as VT, could explain why TKOK wasn't cured

True. TKOK's flip was even added in after the fact so maybe confusion there?

 

[Smart Marx]

Hey @OMB any chance you still think I'm scum? We're kind of waiting on things to happen so I wouldn't mind letting you have another crack at me.