Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

Why would you not redirect a watcher if you’d already killed the tracker?

Only if you had an idea of where he was looking. Otherwise just kill me. Why the charade?

CP's death wasn't pressing enough to use a role of that strength to make sure I didn't see anything.

 

[Evans]

Vote Jeff and I’ll explain why.

I didn’t understand your question because you said I’m protecting Lethal every night, because I’d full claimed and you were asking me whether I was protecting lethal. You didn’t say did I visit lethal or anything else you said am I protecting Lethal - this question doesn’t make sense and my role is passive. I protect Odin, I don’t have to target him, which is why I thought you were fishing. I also buy your usage and I’m not questioning you.

However, we now have a guarantee Jeff is scum.

There is no way in this game we have a watcher, a tracker and a motion detector (although note he hasn’t claimed). It’s too many investigative roles; however even if you buy for a minute the existence of all those roles, there’s no way to explain Smark’s result on CP and my role. If Smark was redirected or similar, he would have seen Jeff target Lethal/CP as well as me. So we know Jeff is lying.

I know Lethal’s character is legit and the fact I’m named in his PM is pretty coincidental even to the skeptics. I had thought maybe I’m his BP as the SK but that’s kind of out there even for this game and I had thought that Brutus was softing Hider which gave me pause on the Lethal claim of Cop - there can’t be both.

Votes on Jeff.

Vote Xenus

Even though I can't vote, I'll vote Xenus just to make my point.

I don't see how you visiting CP has led us to guaranteeing Jeff is scum? Using setup spec that there possibly can't be those roles in the game does not guarantee Jeff is scum. Whilst I have my suspicions over Jeffs push on Lethal, as I do think Lethal is town - this feels like caught scum trying anything to survive. Just like when I caught you out in WS Reloaded. Smark has NAILED you and you're panicking IMO.

I've had this gut feeling all game you're not above board and here it is.

Lynch Xenus and we will have a LOT of info to go off for the rest of the game IMO.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Oh, sounded like you could confirm if a specific character was in the game at all lol.

oh no, I just meant that I know a specific character is in the game right now because of the role pm. I just dont really see the value in saying who atm as it doesnt help us at all.

 

[Xenus]

Can a town roleblocker come forward saying they swapped CP and lethal plz

I don’t think my role can be bus driven as it’s character specific and the theory doesn’t make sense cause then I’d be dead.

 

[Ace]

Why would you not redirect a watcher if you’d already killed the tracker?

Because you would kill them? Particularly with the ninja strongman scum would need to have for this all to make sense.

 

[Xenus]

Only if you had an idea of where he was looking. Otherwise just kill me. Why the charade?

CP's death wasn't pressing enough to use a role of that strength to make sure I didn't see anything.

I think CP was categorically the strongest town read person at the end of D2 no and suspecting Jeff to high heaven.

Look at the kills - they are slimy as fuck. Magic N1 and CP N2.

 

[Lethal]

I think shenanigans are afoot, why would Freki/Geri be mentioned in my PM if they aren't in the game? Just seems a stretch, no? Does Odo have a history of FAKES that can be confirmed? Trying to remember the Nintendo game

 

[Ace]

I don’t think my role can be bus driven as it’s character specific and the theory doesn’t make sense cause then I’d be dead.

OK, so if you believe this, I'm not sure I'm understanding what you think happened here?

Could you explain your theory? Or do you think Smark is just lying.

 

[Xenus]

Because you would kill them? Particularly with the ninja strongman scum would need to have for this all to make sense.

There’s no mention of a ninja strongman. Please read my posts.

 

[Smart Marx]

I think shenanigans are afoot, why would Freki/Geri be mentioned in my PM if they aren't in the game? Just seems a stretch, no? Does Odo have a history of FAKES that can be confirmed? Trying to remember the Nintendo game

I think people look too much into flavor and Odo is probably punishing anyone that uses a fake name to confirm someone over play.

 

[Comrade Khan]

All I will say is Lethal shouldn't be out of the woods yet, that's still too many roles stacked as I said (a full cop with a "if you lynch me it hurts everyone too so ull never lynch me) + a goes through II shot? I honestly don't fucking think so. 3 roles sounds like a potential indy fake maybe

 

[Evans]

I think shenanigans are afoot, why would Freki/Geri be mentioned in my PM if they aren't in the game? Just seems a stretch, no? Does Odo have a history of FAKES that can be confirmed? Trying to remember the Nintendo game

If there's one thing I've learned over the past how many games, if you hear hooves, think horses - not zebras.

He visited CP and CP died whilst trying to claim he's a seraph to you. He's been feeding you drinks all night until you pass out and he makes his move on you whilst you sleep.

 

[Smart Marx]

If there's one thing I've learned over the past how many games, if you hear hooves, think horses - not zebras.

He visited CP and CP died whilst trying to claim he's a seraph to you. He's been feeding you drinks all night until you pass out and he makes his move on you whilst you sleep.

Best analogy(ies) all game.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I think people look too much into flavor and Odo is probably punishing anyone that uses a fake name to confirm someone over play.

100% true, Odo often intentionally tries to do shit like that. it's like...the opposite of how you write your pms id say?

 

[Smart Marx]

100% true, Odo often intentionally tries to do shit like that. it's like...the opposite of how you write your pms id say?

A little, but I also have names in the OP and PMs that aren't characters in the game. A lot of the time it's flavor pertaining to the theme, not game.