Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

Even if it was a ninja who killed CP, why was Xenus seen there? This is a mind fuck, 100%

I did the math. Xenus can’t be a protective role seen visiting CP the night he died. Place a vote please.

 

[Lethal]

Scenes if Smark is faking this info to remove the seraph to kill the cop.

Would make Smark an auto-lynch day 4 and have him lose, which he was almost quitting the game about during D1, so very unlikely.

 

[Smart Marx]

I guess a Seraph Knight would show up in a watcher results. Only way I could see Xenus being town is a ninja strongman. But if he is scum why would he tie himself to you like that? Such a big risk

One of the reasons I focused more on his not visiting Lethal. Look at his response. He was totes gonna say he wouldn’t have been seen visiting him.

But I spilled the beans immediately after that.

And if there’s a ninja strongman, game over.

 

[Smart Marx]

Scenes if Smark is faking this info to remove the seraph to kill the cop.

Would make Smark an auto-lynch day 4 and have him lose, which he was almost quitting the game about during D1, so very unlikely.

I would 100% refuse any auto lynch plays. For sure.

 

[Lethal]

Now I think about it, I was cautious of why he was buddying up to me so much.

Ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

 

[Doddsy]

Smark just for clarification did you get CP or your target?

 

[Xenus]

I'm Heimdallr the Watcher.I'm the warrior and watcher of the Bitfrost. It mentions liking to drink and my trumpet that can be heard in all worlds.

Gjallarhorn is its name and it singles the final battle of Ragnarök.

Vote Jeff and I’ll explain why.

I didn’t understand your question because you said I’m protecting Lethal every night, because I’d full claimed and you were asking me whether I was protecting lethal. You didn’t say did I visit lethal or anything else you said am I protecting Lethal - this question doesn’t make sense and my role is passive. I protect Odin, I don’t have to target him, which is why I thought you were fishing. I also buy your usage and I’m not questioning you.

However, we now have a guarantee Jeff is scum.

There is no way in this game we have a watcher, a tracker and a motion detector (although note he hasn’t claimed). It’s too many investigative roles; however even if you buy for a minute the existence of all those roles, there’s no way to explain Smark’s result on CP and my role. If Smark was redirected or similar, he would have seen Jeff target Lethal/CP as well as me. So we know Jeff is lying.

I know Lethal’s character is legit and the fact I’m named in his PM is pretty coincidental even to the skeptics. I had thought maybe I’m his BP as the SK but that’s kind of out there even for this game and I had thought that Brutus was softing Hider which gave me pause on the Lethal claim of Cop - there can’t be both.

Votes on Jeff.

 

[Smart Marx]

Smark just for clarification did you get CP or your target?

My target.

I highly doubt any shenanigans.

Look at his reactions at every step of the way.

He’s 100% caught scum.

 

[Roy Mustang]

I'm going for a walk to think this through. I agree Jeff is scum. It's whether Xenus is too.

I think Smark and Lethal are town here

 

[Smart Marx]

For the record, Jeff is definitely scum as well. Xenus totes sold him down the river.

 

[Doddsy]

I'm gonna need a Jeff full claim before anything I think

 

[Smart Marx]

I’d almost be willing to lynch Jeff, but I don’t know if I can trust you guys to follow up on Xenus.

 

[Roy Mustang]

For the record, Jeff is definitely scum as well. Xenus totes sold him down the river.

And that's why I'm pausing. I don't get why he would sell him down the river there. Bussing him there would be so bad.

 

[Xenus]

For the record, Jeff is definitely scum as well. Xenus totes sold him down the river.

WIFOM but you think my defence here is to target the Godfather in my own team?

 

[Roy Mustang]

I feel like I'm missing something fucking obvious here