Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

okay so after reviewing I'd say

Town - Grim, Gambit, Tweet, Jeff
Scum - Doddsy, Xenus, weaker scum lean - Lethal, Alco

I'm not hating this list. Any chance you can expand on how you arrived at these reads?

 

[Big Man]

Well I don't plan on sticking around all night

I do look forward to Lethal telling me where he went last night however....

I mean you might as well claim at his point. we've had a tracker so you're a watcher I guess. if lethal is scum then scum already know where he went so you'd only be hiding the info from town which there's no reason to do really.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm not a watcher

 

[Smart Marx]

Brutus is trolling, paying attention to the thread, and apparently faking info on me and admitting to it? .the chance of him being scum are about 0.000000001%

Did he fake info? He was asked and immediately said he had no info, right?

 

[Smart Marx]

I'm not a watcher

Did you say you were?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Did he fake info? He was asked and immediately said he had no info, right?

Something like that, I read back fairly loosely. I just don't really see a scum brutus being so...free. I could have just as easily sheeped a vote on me with no reason no?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I mean you might as well claim at his point. we've had a tracker so you're a watcher I guess. if lethal is scum then scum already know where he went so you'd only be hiding the info from town which there's no reason to do really.

@Demo God was responding to this

 

[Big Man]

Gambit's point about PHEN0M likely jailkeeping Poyser seems legit so magic can be town as PHEN0M wouldn't hint at info on his teammate. magic and gambit are both likely town due to interactions with PHEN0M anyway.

 

[NotBrutus]

well I already see that my read on PHEN0M was incorrect, but the reasoning was the way he went about his push on Poyser/Magic. he put his vote down and then kept coming back to mention it, it seemed like frustration that his direction wasn't being followed. I felt as scum he would just leave it after the initial vote because mentioning it over and over causes more people to look at the reasoning for your read which you don't really want if you're scum and it's a fake read. as for Brutus, he plays pretty cowardly as scum, one game last year he just kept posting in the QT and not in the thread at all because he was too scared. he seems very comfortable in the thread and is asking people good questions and pushing people himself rather than just sheeping.

I just want to point out, I’ve told the full story about that game before, and this wasn’t the reason...

 

[Evans]

Looks like we're starting off with you. For some reason you completely exclude PHENOM from this. At least you're sus of Xenus.

Okay fair play here, perhaps this is why you missed him earlier

I left a few names off my initial reads list as players I either was struggling to read or didn't have anything strong enough to talk about.

The 2nd bit where you quote me & Barry - not sure who that's supposed to be for?

 

[NotBrutus]

@Big Man who do you think is scum? Or town? Whichever answer you prefer

 

[Smart Marx]

Something like that, I read back fairly loosely. I just don't really see a scum brutus being so...free. I could have just as easily sheeped a vote on me with no reason no?

He just placed a vote on you so I don't think he was attempting to fake info, tbh.

I assume the I and me are typos here, but you clarify the bold?

 

[Big Man]

I'm not a watcher

okay well what % would you put on lehtal being scum. I know you said he's lying about his role but is there any chance he was just trying to hide something (i.e. an additional role) as town?

 

[Evans]

Gambit thinks that N0m has info and is hinting his role, what do you think about this? I can see where you're coming from that targeting Magicv2/Poyser instead of other stuff going on in the thread looks if he isn't. I haven't seen anything that suggests a hint. @Gambitto where do you think he's suggesting his role? Do you think it's the hypothetical post? I'm not very good at reading Phen0m at all, so I'm not sure if this is his town meta or not? Does he push big players early as scum?



Big Man, what are your thoughts on the above ^ and what's your reasoning for town reading Phen0m and Brutus?

@Chloe B - this post as well should help you with your thoughts about why I left Phen0m off my reads list

 

[Comrade Khan]

He just placed a vote on you so I don't think he was attempting to fake info, tbh.

I assume the I and me are typos here, but you clarify the bold?

yeh I meant to say he could have just put the vote on me and say nothing and I don't think anyone would have cared at the time