Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Tweet]

@Showtime d1 you were positively urging people to no lynch, but now youre sorry we no lynched d2. What is different d1 to d2 and whom would you have lynched d2?

 

[Roy Mustang]

Well I hope you’re aware of how it came across, especially since town was already massively split by that time. I didn’t see the need to vote each other. Who are your town/scum leads?

I mean I had my vote on Phenom for hours before it (Phenom didn't notice this either).

Scum: Phenom. Not got many others. Town reads have been easier for me this game:

Evans, Lethal, Barry, Smark, TKOK, OMB, Xenus, Chloe aka Flay are my town reads with Evans, Lethal, Smark and Chloe being the strong ones

 

[Lethal]

I don't and I just don't think he's actually done anything to prove himself as town, especially when you take into consideration the significant pivot from "Go ahead and lynch me" to "Please don't lynch me!" after he gave his info, lack of pushes, bunny-ears play, and all around paper pushing. He's ultimately failed to live up to any sort of standard town play.

Had you have put in "good-guy read" you'd have nailed the hat-trick

Especially when you consider he's active in other threads and appears to be avoiding this thread.

That's quite the WIFOM

Yeah I get this but his play and he the fact he isn't afraid to be a bit antagonistic to players feels like town OMB for me. I think we're going to need to confirm the census eventually. I just don't see OMB using his role like that as scum.

iirc it was Poyser who nabbed his meta a few games back. Town OMB will paint every scum with crazy theories and "hunch" feels, not really going to any further explanantion. Scum OMB gives off town reads only. Could his meta have changed? Sure, but would this be a natural progression based on feedback? Can't say I've ever seen a scum census, might do some research

Literally asked everyone on it questions the night after

Fantastic, but your analysis is....where exactly?

 

[CraigPelton]

So much consensus on town reads and yet we can't agree on a lynch. This seems off.

 

[CraigPelton]

Hope the SK realizes that they need to be trying to hit mafia to give town something to work with or else they will have no chance.

 

[Lethal]

The hesistance to lynch yesterday could be something to consider as well, where a lynch stalled and so many split wagons, yet Haza's wagon gained steam and was always running on momentum

 

[Xenus]

@Showtime d1 you were positively urging people to no lynch, but now youre sorry we no lynched d2. What is different d1 to d2 and whom would you have lynched d2?

I can’t wait for Magic to reply to this.

 

[NotBrutus]

So much consensus on town reads and yet we can't agree on a lynch. This seems off.

I was just gonna say this, lol.

I mean I had my vote on Phenom for hours before it (Phenom didn't notice this either).

Scum: Phenom. Not got many others. Town reads have been easier for me this game:

Evans, Lethal, Barry, Smark, TKOK, OMB, Xenus, Chloe aka Flay are my town reads with Evans, Lethal, Smark and Chloe being the strong ones

Weren’t you town reading Phen0m early in the game due to him putting unnecessary attention on himself, which he normally wouldn’t do as scum? Plus he was actually paying attention and answering questions.

 

[NotBrutus]

I guess we can deal with the Gambit/Phen0m when the time comes...

I’d much rather look at Jeff and, or, Magic tomorrow.

 

[Smart Marx]

The hesistance to lynch yesterday could be something to consider as well, where a lynch stalled and so many split wagons, yet Haza's wagon gained steam and was always running on momentum

There was definitely scum pushing that Haza and most likely one or more wagons yesterday were of scum.

Cross referencing those two days could be helpful.

 

[Doddsy]

Do you have a track record of reading Brutus? I honestly can't remember how long he's been playing with us.

Kek I was gonna apologize for not being around at EoD but looks like it wasn't gonna make a difference anyway


I gave Chloe an explanation for why I voted Haza, and I gave Xenus the reasons I was sus of him and he unvoted so it appears the explanation is sufficient for him. What is left that I haven't adressed?

Want to quote it for me I don't remember it

@Showtime d1 you were positively urging people to no lynch, but now youre sorry we no lynched d2. What is different d1 to d2 and whom would you have lynched d2?

Is this an actual question?

 

[Chloe B]

Had you have put in "good-guy read" you'd have nailed the hat-trick





That's quite the WIFOM



iirc it was Poyser who nabbed his meta a few games back. Town OMB will paint every scum with crazy theories and "hunch" feels, not really going to any further explanantion. Scum OMB gives off town reads only. Could his meta have changed? Sure, but would this be a natural progression based on feedback? Can't say I've ever seen a scum census, might do some research



Fantastic, but your analysis is....where exactly?

Lel what?

I been analysing, pay attention to the game

 

[Roy Mustang]

I was just gonna say this, lol.



Weren’t you town reading Phen0m early in the game due to him putting unnecessary attention on himself, which he normally wouldn’t do as scum? Plus he was actually paying attention and answering questions.

The first part I don't remember saying. That sounds like something CP said I think. Phenom has been trying but his day 2 play feels scummy as hell (pushing Posyer/Magic V2 still and the vote on me)

 

[Lethal]

Odo Hosting History:

Final Fantasy - no census
NFL - no census
Metal Gear - no census
Yu-Gi-Oh - no census
Persona 5 - no census
Ace Attorney - no census (had an actor with DV powers though, it was Barry fwiw)
Three Kingdoms - no census
WWE Jobbers - no census
Nintendo - no census

So I think it really random that suddenly we now have a census in the game that is claimed by an erratic player. Someone even said Odo is on record saying he HATES the role, so I doubt he puts it in. Yeah Lethal, don't try and outguess the host, but the history speaks for itself. He was all happy to be the lynch (OMB), then said not to lynch him. Barry was keen to prove his legitimacy (bussing?) and then it's suddenly dropped on D2.

Food for thought

 

[Lethal]

Lel what?

I been analysing, pay attention to the game

I am, and I notice that your analysis of the D1 wagon is missing, yet you're directing others to analyse it? See my issue?