No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Pendex]

Sky suggested John Win the duel and we Lynch Gacy, yes.

Sky suggested we lynch McHenry, while having Gacy lose the Duel.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Unvote: Gacy

Lynch Vote: McHenry

Stupid sexy McHenry

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

if Gacy wins the duel - McHenry dies

So he does. Tripping all over my own dick here trying to keep shit straight. Apologies, Juice.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Oh well I used my role thought I was being helpful

 

[Pendex]

I suppose I'll sleep on it. Objectively, excercising caution would work here too but... @Gacy were you aware that this would shift the lynch?

 

[CakeWalker]

Gacy starting this duel doesn't seem like a mafia move. Wanting him to die - doesn't make any sense to me. This game makes zero sense to me now.

 

[Smart Marx]

That's what I figured.

Vote: John

Vote: John McHenry

I'm headed back to bed for the night. Need to actually go to work to get paid. Night everyone

So this is an interesting entrance because I think there were some concerns about how John can be a bit inactive as scum. Seems like he wants to make sure people know he's inactive for a good reason. Why not just until you were freer to make your first post?

He makes six reads that I think are pretty fence sitting and gives us no indication of where he's leaning. Then he does give some suss to Ekko's slot (he'll later say Ekko is the easiest D1 lynch). Says me and Tommy are playing exactly like we have before and we're town core. That's a very confident statement so early in the game. Not even sure how many posts I would have had at the time.

Here is John being worried about Tommy making comments about inactivity.

Another activity comment.

Glad I could summon him.

I'm actually confused with this because he already posted these reads? He sits the fence with the same players, except makes a comment on Ratchet not engaging in anything overtly scummy (even though he'll go on to vote Ratchet later). Not sure why he's putting forward reads with no real content?

Defends me here.

Here's the infamous post of being fine with Ekko. Not sure about the bolded?

Not sure why you would say Ekko is the easiest D1 lynch but then defer to me? If you know anything about me and Ekko's history, I am absolutely NOT having him anywhere near being a D1 wagon.

What does talking about modkills have to do anything with being easy? This is some shitty shade.

Somehow I missed his Ratchet vote in my iso? But yeah, the pivot to Sky is bad.

Already starting to backpedal. I also bolded this because he'll accuse Tommy of being scummy because of him misreading and inferring things.

Says misremembering is fine.

Offers up Sky and Juice now. Interesting interaction to try and get people to discuss.

Not sure why he wants to talk to Jeff?

John is a magic Jeff reader? wtf

Okay, is Ekko easy? Is he scummy? Is he calculated? You've kind of thrown out a few things around Ekko's slot and look defensive around your early vote for him. I don't like how you backtracked on two of your reads. Feels like you have no conviction.

I mean, I feel like with only playing five or six games, to say that he always gets picked D1 seems like an appeal to emotion. If this is true, there must be a reason for that? I don't remember John being a weak player and remember him in the Nile game and how far he made it. Don't like he is saying lynch for info.

Shades both but doesn't really commit on who could be scum and why.

Still sitting the fence here. If you think one of them is scum, which is it? Feels like an easy way to mislynch two people.

Not sure why he's worried about dying at night?

This is John saying wolf Barry could shoot wolf Tpein if Tpein wanted to sub out. Not sure how he knows this two so intimately he could determine this?

But as John previously stated, misremembering is okay! Seems like a cheap attempt to shift attention from him.


Vote John McHenry

I think that there is more than enough reasons here for me to vote here. I haven't seen any scum hunting from John and he has only thrown out easy options, only to backtrack, after being called out for his votes. He has offered little for a defense against his accusations and I'm not seeing any townie energy here, either to solve slots, or help solve his slot.

Vote: John to Win

Vote Lynch: Gacy

DUEL WINNER: GACY

VOTE: GRIM

Welcome to the Enchanted Forest: Once Upon a Time Mafia!
A boy contacts his long-lost mother who gave him up for adoption and convinces her to follow him to Storybrooke, Maine,
where storybook characters who inhabit the town are trapped by an evil queen.

Midday 1 Vote Count

Ekkologix (1) - PHEN0M
Sky (1) - John McHenry
The Grimch (1) - Turanga Leela
Mandalorian (1) - T-Pein™
John McHenry (6) - Silent Bite, Tommy Bedlam, Sky, Mandalorian, Cereal Killer, Sister Abigail
Gacy (1) - The Grimch

Duel Standings

John McHenry (1) - The Grimch
Gacy (1) - Turanga Leela

With 18 players remaining in the game, it takes 10 votes to reach a lynch.

Day 1 will end on Thursday at 8:33 AM ET.​

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I legitimately thought I was doing a helpful move.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I legitimately thought I was doing a helpful move.

You are lol

 

[CakeWalker]

I legitimately thought I was doing a helpful move.

I think it was helpful - but people are being lazy AF right now and going to try and kill you off. Rather than using your duel to kill McHenry and using the lynch on another scum suspect

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

@Hayterade didn’t Grim also vote to Lynch John? Or did he unvote and me miss it?

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

You are lol

I don't see how me dying is going to help I'm a town number. It's not like I'm lying bout my role. Plus I hinted at doing this all day

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

offcial duel winner: gacy

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I think it was helpful - but people are being lazy AF right now and going to try and kill you off. Rather than using your duel to kill McHenry and using the lynch on another scum suspect

I don’t think it’s lazy. It’s entirely feasible that a scum Gacy went duel on a scum McHenry since the train was 70% filled on him. Scum bussing scum who is already almost a guaranteed lynch isn’t unheard of

 

[Smart Marx]

Goddamn it, that’s what I meant. I got myself crossed up.

Vote: McHenry to win the duel

Still voting to lynch McHenry

Unvote: Gacy

Lynch Vote: McHenry

Stupid sexy McHenry

Welcome to the Enchanted Forest: Once Upon a Time Mafia!
A boy contacts his long-lost mother who gave him up for adoption and convinces her to follow him to Storybrooke, Maine,
where storybook characters who inhabit the town are trapped by an evil queen.

Midday 1 Vote Count

Ekkologix (1) - PHEN0M
Sky (1) - John McHenry
The Grimch (1) - Turanga Leela
Mandalorian (1) - T-Pein™
John McHenry (7) - Silent Bite, Tommy Bedlam, Sky, Mandalorian, Cereal Killer, Sister Abigail, The Grimch

Duel Standings

John McHenry (2) - The Grimch, Tommy Bedlam
Gacy (1) - Turanga Leela

With 18 players remaining in the game, it takes 10 votes to reach a lynch.

Day 1 will end on Thursday at 8:33 AM ET.​