I've interacted with him a few times this game and he seemed townieWas actually trying to figure out why you've auto cleared Tommy - other than saying, coz i think he is town.
There is a lot of reasons - why he could be mafia. And him being mafia - could be a plausible way you're not mafia.
if he is scum I have no idea why scum jeff makes the kill day 4 and not tommy
his claim checks out and scum didn't need to counter claim baldy, and they certainly didnt need tommy to be the one to do it
so ya it checks out to me? 100%? no, but I'm not 100% on anything