New York. New Rules. Scream VI Mafia Game Thread

[Doc Sulliday]

I don't like how this is being rushed by Sky and I don't like how dismissive Ultra is of my theory on why she'd be lying.

I did the math. If there's another two kill night with a mislynch it's 3-4.

I almost am 95% sure that at least one GF is going to be BP/LP. Ghostface is notorious for taking multiple shots to take down (aim for the head). If they can manipulate it the right way they could totally play the numbers when it's 3-4 with a death proof perk and win right there.

 

[CakeWalker]

but yeah - Lethal's return without info would probably just see me return my vote.

 

[Sky]

I don't like how this is being rushed by Sky and I don't like how dismissive Ultra is of my theory on why she'd be lying.

I did the math. If there's another two kill night with a mislynch it's 3-4.

I almost am 95% sure that at least one GF is going to be BP/LP. Ghostface is notorious for taking multiple shots to take down (aim for the head). If they can manipulate it the right way they could totally play the numbers when it's 3-4 with a death proof perk and win right there.

John being town requires Mando to also be lying

 

[Doc Sulliday]

I’m absolutely fine not rushing this but I think we have to solve this today and I’m more inclined to believe Sky than McHenry. It’s annoying as I really think we’d have got mafia with Gipper had this not come up.

I’ve got football training and then pub so I’ll be gone for a few hours.

I think Occam's razor says that John is the easy vote and that's ultimately where I'm probably going to go, but Sky and Ultra right now first of all seem super intertwined, and second Sky not wanting to wait for Lethal is super weird when the day started a couple hours ago.

You're literally in Lethals timezone no?

 

[CakeWalker]

no Mando is is mine. Lethal is like 11 hours or more ahead

 

[Mandalorian]

I think Occam's razor says that John is the easy vote and that's ultimately where I'm probably going to go, but Sky and Ultra right now first of all seem super intertwined, and second Sky not wanting to wait for Lethal is super weird when the day started a couple hours ago.

You're literally in Lethals timezone no?

Nah I’m UK and Lethal is Oceania.

 

[CakeWalker]

part of me is wary, that John has role claimed - but Sky has just offered info without a role claim.

 

[John McHenry]

John being town requires Mando to also be lying

No it doesn't. It only required you to read his info and piggyback off it then feign ignorance claiming to not have seen it.


What's your opinion on the gipper debate?

 

[Doc Sulliday]

Nah I’m UK and Lethal is Oceania.

Ah got it. In that case it's like 4am in Lethal's time.

Which also, I was posting at 4am a couple days ago. So assuming Lethal won't be around is assuming Lethal has a normal sleep schedule.

But if lethal does have a normal schedule then they'll be awake in like 4 hours or so no?

 

[The Gipper]

Also

Official Vote: McHenry

Yeah no shit. I expect John to vote me in a bit.

 

[Doc Sulliday]

No it doesn't. It only required you to read his info and piggyback off it then feign ignorance claiming to not have seen it.


What's your opinion on the gipper debate?

So Sky is saying you targeted Grim. And you're claiming you didn't at all?

 

[Doc Sulliday]

Also

Official Vote: McHenry

Yeah no shit. I expect John to vote me in a bit.

Why would he vote you? If Sky is lying he's the only one who'd know for sure. Why would he vote you over her?

 

[Doc Sulliday]

No it doesn't. It only required you to read his info and piggyback off it then feign ignorance claiming to not have seen it.


What's your opinion on the gipper debate?

Similarly to my response to Gipper...

Why are you still interested in the Gipper vote when Sky should be your #1 target at this point if you know she's lying?

 

[John McHenry]

Why would he vote you? If Sky is lying he's the only one who'd know for sure. Why would he vote you over her?

Right I was going to vote him, but Sky's forced me to vote for her, because she's protecting him.

 

[Sky]

No it doesn't. It only required you to read his info and piggyback off it then feign ignorance claiming to not have seen it.

He would need to be lying about knowing there is an SK in this game, which would make his claim fake.

That would fix the scum team as me, Mando, and Ultra according to you @Sully - do you really think this?