Honestly, I think Sky is right. There’s a very small chance she’s not town and is a mafia tracker or watcher, but through my role I know there’s almost certainly an SK in the game and we had two kills last night which supports that.
The theory I put out there of a SK trying to get town points by killing mafia fits (remember the first Simpsons game when I killed two mafia players and almost won?) and McHenry I believe was one of those who said they were sus of Grim.
This, if true, also means that SS was killed by mafia and killing SS N1 is a fantastic way of framing me for those who know the relationship between us. Which really now out of those left would be you, Gipper, Tommy and Wang due to FWA.
Obviously there is mafia incentive for getting rid of the SK, but it also helps town as well because with another two townies dead tonight if we don’t do this and Sky happens to be right, and we’re in a terrible position as potentially another two towns go tonight.
I also absolutely agree that Gipper looks like shit if Sky is wrong here. But there’s definitely an SK and if Sky is mafia - even on the off chance - I don’t see why she’d make this play if McHenry isn’t the SK because then the actual one is still out there and can still potentially shoot mafia.
