New York. New Rules. Scream VI Mafia Game Thread

[CakeWalker]

i mean i dont know if sky is claimed to be watcher or tracker. not even a soft.

 

[CakeWalker]

what if Sky is lying - John dies. Then Lethal is lynched - end up being Sky's direct cc.

 

[Doc Sulliday]

i mean i dont know if sky is claimed to be watcher or tracker. not even a soft.

Does it make a difference, right now at this vote?

Are you considering Sky is lying?

 

[CakeWalker]

the rushing of this lynch - without Lethal's prescence. Show that their is mafia on the wagon.

Sky lack of actual claiming, of anything but info isn't actually evidence of anything. The very role she is suggesting is mafia, could literally be a WIFOM

 

[CakeWalker]

Does it make a difference, right now at this vote?

Are you considering Sky is lying?

with both things ive said taking place, i believe it is possible

 

[Sky]

is this you're role?

I thought it was self evident that I was one of the two, given the previous posting of how I can only be one of two roles. My info that a specific person visited someone else is compatible with those roles and only those roles. Is this just an act? Are you pretending you don't know this?

 

[The Gipper]

If we still had a roleblocker and SS wasn't killed, do you think Lethal or Juice would be one to roleblock?

Or John if he survives this lynch (because I gurantee you there's a deathrpoof GF)

Question:

“There will be a lot of role overlap.
Some of the time it will be town/town, scum/scum, or even town/scum so I wouldn't hunt on this alone.”

this is from the op, I could be wrong but why are we sure there isn’t another roleblocker in this situation?

 

[Doc Sulliday]

what if Sky is lying - John dies. Then Lethal is lynched - end up being Sky's direct cc.

No. If Sky is lying she CANNOT be the lynch in Lylo.

If that's a play then the only reason they used Sky is because they know she'll be lynched for lying, and she probably has a deathproof.

We'd have to go elsewhere.

But at this point we're working ourselves. Gotta go with the Occam's razor first.

 

[Ultra]

your unwillingness to claim your role - really makes me sus you here.

I don't necessarily agree - with the claims given it leaves very little room for doubt that McHenry is lying, if the result is all the same what does further clarification give us

 

[CakeWalker]

I thought it was self evident that I was one of the two, given the previous posting of how I can only be one of two roles. My info that a specific person visited someone else is compatible with those roles and only those roles. Is this just an act? Are you pretending you don't know this?

you've not given us info that tells us your town though. without an actual claim - would could easily be using information garned by the mafia team.

 

[John McHenry]

No. If Sky is lying she CANNOT be the lynch in Lylo.

If that's a play then the only reason they used Sky is because they know she'll be lynched for lying, and she probably has a deathproof.

We'd have to go elsewhere.

But at this point we're working ourselves. Gotta go with the Occam's razor first.

Then make her answer why she targeted Grim.

What reason did she have? She can't come up with one after like an hour cause she's making it up.

 

[CakeWalker]

logicaly - if I was mafia. I would have just bussed John and let the day end. What i am doing, is from a position of a town member

 

[Doc Sulliday]

Question:

“There will be a lot of role overlap.
Some of the time it will be town/town, scum/scum, or even town/scum so I wouldn't hunt on this alone.”

this is from the op, I could be wrong but why are we sure there isn’t another roleblocker in this situation?

That actually makes sense. We could potentially be dealing with a situation like that. Especially if the theory about Lethal is true.

If John is mafia Jango basically gave her and Lethal away. Was anyone else not on yet besides Lethal? Like Wang? Why did Jango just want to wait for Lethal?

 

[CakeWalker]

if me and Lethal were scum with John - it be effectively throwing the game here.

 

[Doc Sulliday]

Then make her answer why she targeted Grim.

What reason did she have? She can't come up with one after like an hour cause she's making it up.

Did she say she did? I didn't see her say that. If that's the case it's because it'd give away whether she's watcher or tracker. If she's tracker she didn't target Grim. She targeted you, probably because you're on your sus list.

If she's watcher, she's picking someone she thinks is probably a N1 kill candidate, and with Grim being a town leader in most games he is definitely a good watch. He'd probably be someone I watched too.