Murder On The Orient Express [A Detective's Adventure Part I]

[Alco]

Oh and Ace Dalton offered to rep in as well!

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Oh and Ace Dalton offered to rep in as well!

yeah thats true, i talked to him yesterday and he was sad he couldnt play. good guy alco

 

[Doddsy]

Also @Doddsy something I picked up on that you said about Lethals role

In your 5 player example, you claimed that player 5s vote disappears, and gets added to player 3. Thats not how lethals role works - his vote remains on the player he voted, all that happens is that the hypothetical player 3 gets the double vote

Ah okay that's my bad, I thought it just gave his vote to who is vote was on. There's definitely more utility in that than I thought, but I still think it'd be discernible after a few uses.

Honestly re-affirms that Lethal isn't scum as he doesn't give that info up for no reason, as that gives away any utility it had for no gain. Could be a way to help him indy win earlier though, so probably increases the indy odds

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I mean tl/dr it sounds like

doddsy: I don't think the way he laid out his claim/prove his role is scum for lethal
odo: believes the role itself is either nai or scummy, and that lethal botched trying to make himself look towny out of it, and is scum.

sound about right?

 

[CakeWalker]

Oh and Ace Dalton offered to rep in as well!

If a replacement is needed - Ace is first reserve.

 

[Odo]

I think lethal fucked up voting to give flay the gift, ostensibly cause he saw me do it, and then when i railroaded him, he panicked and spilt the beans

 

[Doddsy]

I mean tl/dr it sounds like

doddsy: I don't think the way he laid out his claim/prove his role is scum for lethal
odo: believes the role itself is either nai or scummy, and that lethal botched trying to make himself look towny out of it, and is scum.

sound about right?

For the most part yes.

I think lethal fucked up voting to give flay the gift, ostensibly cause he saw me do it, and then when i railroaded him, he panicked and spilt the beans

But why would he give up the vote portion of is role, all he needed was the gift giver claim

 

[Doddsy]

And why would he make such a large deal about his role and the vagueness of it. Doesn't line up

 

[Odo]

Because its lethal. His ability to shit the bed is unrivalled

 

[Alco]

The same way you don't see him doing it, Doddsy, I totally see Lethal panicking and throwing it all out there in an attempt to save himself.

And he did, effectively, for at least a day.

 

[Poyser]

How much thought do you think lethal puts into this stuff lol

 

[Odo]

its also 23 hours since he last posted

 

[Odo]

when he comes in and says hes been asleep. ill mark

 

[Alco]

And didn’t you say cp was pro lethal? So how’s that a safe choice? I’m confused

Sorry I never replied to this.

If CP thinks Lethal is town, Lethal could very well see it a safe choice to kill him as he'd never fall under suspicion.
I'm trying to look into Lethal's mind here.

 

[Odo]

Cp only thought he was town based on 'too many people' thinking he was town

I dont even think this stands up to scrutiny, there was only junk and doddsy saying he was town yesterday, right?