I love the COD games, but in all honesty, I hated them at first but in time they grew on me. I cannot say the same for Halo. I also thought that the Need for Speed series was over rated. Someone said The Sims was puke worthy - I will admit that The Sims 1 was not a great game. But The Sims 2 and the Sims 3 are off the chains. Actually, The Sims 1 was off the chains if you got the expansion packs. Maybe it was my "God" complex - but I love The Sims. But MOST over rated game? For me its an easy pick...Counterstrike.
So much pomp and circumstance, so much hype, and such a let down. Call of Duty actually accomplished what CS thought they would accomplish. Nevertheles,s that's my opinion.