MLB 12 The Show or MLB 2k12 ??

[melo]

Well with the upcoming tuesday release of these two mlb games which will you guys be getting if any. Ill be getting the show for sure 2k is terrible except in basketball the demo for 2k12 is total rubbish

 

[The New F'n Show]

Have gotten The Show for the last 5 years while I tempted to change with JV on the cover, I'll stick with it I think.

 

[Deuce]

In my opinion, The Show has always been better than 2k except for NBA 2k12, that game is amazing. I will be picking up both and trying them both out, my friend is willing to buy the one that I don't like so it's a win-win situation for me.

 

[melo]

Just picked up my copy of the show cant wait to start playing

 

[Deuce]

Just picked up my copy of the show cant wait to start playing

You should tell me how it is, I don't get paid until Friday so I can't buy it just yet.

 

[Ben]

Always preferred 2k...presentation may not be as good, but the gameplay trumps the show by a mile.

 

[melo]

the show is beast this year looks so good the pulse pitching is fantastic havent played much but id rate it no lower than an 8.5 still waiting for online to open up

 

[Deuce]

the show is beast this year looks so good the pulse pitching is fantastic havent played much but id rate it no lower than an 8.5 still waiting for online to open up

All I need is the money, I used all my money today for other stuff, will definitely be picking it up if you can't even rate it lower than 8.5.

 

[melo]

that 8.5 is just from me and im a show mark but yeh i honestly think its worth the buy and also challenge of the week is all free this year aswell thats the mode ill play for hours lol

 

[Deuce]

Then I will probably buy it, I like The Show too but I have heard from many people that 2K is better.

 

[Ben]

Show has been getting better reviews from what I've seen, 2k12 has been the one that I've not been hearing positive things about, maybe I'll make the switch this year.

 

[Deuce]

Show has been getting better reviews from what I've seen, 2k12 has been the one that I've not been hearing positive things about, maybe I'll make the switch this year.

I have been looking into the reviews myself as well and I agree, the reviews for The Show are much better so it makes me think that The Show might actually be better than 2K this year.

 

[IA-SteveB]

Good to see some opinions. I have bought the Show for the last four seasons and will probably continue that trend.

 

[melo]

i honestly think the only sports game that 2k does well is nba

 

[TheOneKnownAsFetter]

I played the Show for years but since I switched to 360 in all honest opinion 2K is a better sports franchise period.