Midnight Mass Mafia Game Thread — Game ended.

[Pendex]

i mean, it’s Peter and this game is clearly a dumpster fire but I don’t really see myself not voting pendex here

...?

 

[CraigPelton]

Sir ima need you to claim the other role

I could but it's a strictly -ev move for town which I am now more certain is my alignment than it is yours

 

[Chris]

@Suplexorcist what result did you get back on Jeff when you copped him exactly?

 

[Comrade Khan]

if the christians are town now thats interesting smark. theme hunting and a bit of a touchy point though so its probably not worth exploring today

 

[Smart Marx]

yeah that kind of explains why you didnt say shit and then went on me after poyser. protect your role. ok i can respect that

I was dong my best to nudge other people's reads to you and let them do the work while also myself saying I thought you were scum.

Figured if I could catch you AND Lethal, would be pretty cool before I needed to come out and who knows, I might have gotten Lethal without claiming.

 

[Pendex]

Like I was hinting this all night phase lol. Hence why I said Poyser was lock town. Because I didn't die. But then the kill failing thing meant Poyser could still be scum.

 

[Poyser]

I could but it's a strictly -ev move for town which I am now more certain is my alignment than it is yours

Are there games where this isn’t the case?

terrible reasoning, claim

 

[Comrade Khan]

Are there games where this isn’t the case?

terrible reasoning, claim

i mean i know what it is obviously

 

[Smart Marx]

@Suplexorcist what result did you get back on Jeff when you copped him exactly?

God's Army-aligned

So I don't think Jeff is scum anymore.

 

[Tweet]

I also just remembered I played a Retep game before, it was that Hockey HOF game where I drew that ridiculously OP Gretzky JOAT role

 

[Chris]

Like I was hinting this all night phase lol. Hence why I said Poyser was lock town. Because I didn't die. But then the kill failing thing meant Poyser could still be scum.

I know hider and cop doesn't really compute but this is a good point guys lol why would pendex first confirm poyser and then realize it wasn't even true as a scum play?

 

[Comrade Khan]

and in this case cp isnt wrong to not want to say it, but i wont speak for him or the rest of town

 

[Comrade Khan]

God's Army-aligned

So I don't think Jeff is scum anymore.

that is correct

 

[Poyser]

if the christians are town now thats interesting smark. theme hunting and a bit of a touchy point though so its probably not worth exploring today

Peter said the threat comes not from the island and smark says his character is on the island so it’s moot character spec anyway. He’s either town or it’s a fake lol, character spec is pointless

 

[Poyser]

i mean i know what it is obviously

Yea, but for obvious reasons I don’t trust you