Meltzer's Extreme Rules Star Ratings (3 matches get 4 stars)

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Showstopper

The Icon That Can Still Go
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
3,709
Reaction score
1,029
Points
113
Location
North Jersey
Owens/Murphy: 3.25 stars
Nak/Cesaro vs. New Day: 2.75 stars
Bayley/Cross: 3.25 stars
Rollins/Mysterio: 4 stars
Asuka/Sasha: 4 stars
Drew/Dolph: 4 stars
Braun/Bray: No rating given

Per this weeks WON:
 

Chris

Dreams are Endless
Joined
Dec 23, 2011
Messages
383,800
Reaction score
155,590
Points
128
Age
28
Location
Texas
Favorite Wrestler
tLCb5kv
Favorite Wrestler
OEndG4L
Favorite Wrestler
ArsUxsj
Favorite Wrestler
mrperfect2
Favorite Wrestler
eelOIL6
Favorite Wrestler
BryanDanielson1
Favorite Sports Team
sfa
Favorite Sports Team
dallascowboys
Favorite Sports Team
sanantoniospurs
Favorite Sports Team
texasrangers
This actually kinda shocks me from Dave. I've long realized I mostly agreed with his ratings in the vacuum of one show as far as what are the best and worst matches, but I start having issues when comparing ratings between companies. But I did really fucks with the 3 **** star matches he handed out, just wouldn't have expected him to :lol
 

Showstopper

The Icon That Can Still Go
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
3,709
Reaction score
1,029
Points
113
Location
North Jersey
This actually kinda shocks me from Dave. I've long realized I mostly agreed with his ratings in the vacuum of one show as far as what are the best and worst matches, but I start having issues when comparing ratings between companies. But I did really fucks with the 3 **** star matches he handed out, just wouldn't have expected him to :lol
Yeah man. I'm espacially suprised with the Seth/Rey rating only due to the 'eye' thing. Thought that would 'ruin' it for Dave. But even he said the wrestling was excellent. So, it's good to see he could see that, because it was.

And the Asuka/Sasha and Dolph/Drew matches were excellent, as well.
 
Last edited:

Chris

Dreams are Endless
Joined
Dec 23, 2011
Messages
383,800
Reaction score
155,590
Points
128
Age
28
Location
Texas
Favorite Wrestler
tLCb5kv
Favorite Wrestler
OEndG4L
Favorite Wrestler
ArsUxsj
Favorite Wrestler
mrperfect2
Favorite Wrestler
eelOIL6
Favorite Wrestler
BryanDanielson1
Favorite Sports Team
sfa
Favorite Sports Team
dallascowboys
Favorite Sports Team
sanantoniospurs
Favorite Sports Team
texasrangers
Yeah man. I'm espacially suprised with the Seth/Rey rating only due to the 'eye' thing. Thought that would 'ruin' it for Dave. But even he said the wrestling was excellent. So, it's good to see he could see that, because it was.

Tbf we were all saying how good the match was while watching too, they did a good job keeping the gimmick from being too much until the very end :lol
 

Showstopper

The Icon That Can Still Go
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
3,709
Reaction score
1,029
Points
113
Location
North Jersey
Tbf we were all saying how good the match was while watching too, they did a good job keeping the gimmick from being too much until the very end :lol
Yeah, for sure. It was excellent. Just sometimes the way Dave can be an 'elitist' (no pun intended), I half expected him to shit on it just due to the stip and ending. Glad he didn't.
 

Grimoire Lenin

Social Progressive
Joined
Mar 7, 2019
Messages
92,071
Reaction score
30,035
Points
118
Age
28
Location
Sleepy Eye
Favorite Wrestler
Hv5zY64
Favorite Wrestler
OZO8olA
Favorite Wrestler
zPa7dqi
Favorite Wrestler
Y2tTaaf
Favorite Wrestler
q9gbHdQ
Favorite Wrestler
Y06mUrE
Favorite Sports Team
timberwolves
Favorite Sports Team
wild
Favorite Sports Team
HDDZGPE
Favorite Sports Team
pUtq1ms
So not a bad match on the card, just shite endings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitC

Sabretooth

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2011
Messages
77,227
Reaction score
9,534
Points
113
Age
26
Glad to see that endings don’t ruin matches for him. Maybe people on this website can learn a thing or two from him :swamps
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hidden Blaze

Hidden Blaze

The Wanted Man
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Messages
207,375
Reaction score
72,494
Points
128
Age
33
Location
Crawford County, GA
Favorite Wrestler
chrisjericho
Favorite Wrestler
MOLAnG4
Favorite Wrestler
edge
Favorite Wrestler
homd3TG
Favorite Sports Team
gLxCq87
Favorite Sports Team
WrE8t1L
Favorite Sports Team
lurU13l
Favorite Sports Team
HHst8yg
So if you take out the Swamp match, it was nice a nicely built show with a strong ending


Sent from my Nokia 3310 using Tapatalk