Given the Dynamite numbers, I think Toni came out of the program as the bigger star. AEW's women division is still rocking right now - Toni is one of the top draws in the company, Willow is looking like a star after DoN, Mercedes/Toni is a big deal match for All In, Megan Bayne has been built well, Thekla is coming in, Statlander and Hayter, Harley is making waves...
Do I wish she would've stayed. Absolutely. And I'm worried about how well she'll be handled in WWE but I do wish her the best. And hope she comes back some day. But AEW will be fine.