Mafia Rankings 2021

[Chris]

Playing without a godfather would be rough.

But agreed on outing the cop. Mafia irl you don’t ever claim a role. I’ve seen games where the cop waiting until he knew for sure he was getting lynched before ever coming out. Cops are supposed to subtly move the town to a scum without saying they caught them.

It’s quite fun.

Yeah thats 100% the philosophy we had playing. Cop only outed himself and any shots if he was 100% about to be lynched. It isn't the end of the world bc then the doc should be on him every night if he's not also outed but if you've outed the doc then RIP to both

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I think a universal backup sorta fixes that issue on some level because it's good play on scum to get rid of both.

Just not sure exactly if it's unfair for scum though to have a backup role.

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah thats 100% the philosophy we had playing. Cop only outed himself and any shots if he was 100% about to be lynched. It isn't the end of the world bc then the doc should be on him every night if he's not also outed but if you've outed the doc then RIP to both

If the doctor comes out, it’s game over. Especially if they can’t save consecutive nights.

One of my favorite scum tactics is wait until it’s 2-1, last phase and they claim cop immediately upon waking up, claims to have checked the vt, buddying them, and he says he checked the cop and they’re scum.

I’ve seen it work. Because you question why the cop didn’t come out first and the scum says you’re clear.

 

[Junkette]

I’m not big on classic vanilla games, a vanilla i csn dig is when you spice up the roles, say mafia godfather/bodyguard/goon, SK and a town cop/roleblock but you make it closed!

 

[Poyser]

Updated. Rankings skewed towards the people that have drawn mafia this year lmao. Just a little bit

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

13th place

 

[Hidden Blaze]

31st place

 

[Marty McFourth]

Updated. Rankings skewed towards the people that have drawn mafia this year lmao. Just a little bit

Thanks for taking the time to do it dude, appreciate it.

I'm pretty proud of myself for being in 8th place, I have won an MVP as town and scum this year. I never would have expected that.

Hopefully in 2022 I can continue to catch games when I have the time.

 

[Poyser]

You’re killin it man

 

[Marty McFourth]

To think I was just going to join your Throwback Music game as a one off too, Poyser getting me back in to this

 

[Poyser]

To think I was just going to join your Throwback Music game as a one off too, Poyser getting me back in to this

Lmao to be fair that was a nice easy game to get yourself back into. You won on D2!

 

[Comrade Khan]

Thanks for the update poyser

 

[Chris]

Just below Flay

 

[Comrade Khan]

That's a very nice ppg 4th ! And yes, it's certainly been a scummy year. An outlier year? Or was last year the outlier? 2022 should shed some light

 

[Poyser]

Tbf I’m putting it mostly down to the new breed. Town obviously isn’t half as strong without people like Odo, magic, ace, Rugrat etc playing. I’m sure there’ll be improvement