Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Ace]

Jeff, is Doddsy a scumread of yours, or is he just a null in POE who you're happy enough to follow everyone else on?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Null?

Well yeah but then Id literally say I read you null. In this case, I was also deciding between barry and doddsy (see above), so yeah it this case, me having to reason to read him town = I think he's likely (or likelier, if you want to be a stickler for wording) to be scum.

 

[Rugrat]

I'm with Jeff:

Most people rarely ever give scum town reads. Usually they're just in the big pile of null and whatnot with other town - unless they do some

 

[Comrade Khan]

Jeff, is Doddsy a scumread of yours, or is he just a null in POE who you're happy enough to follow everyone else on?

I kind of answered above already, but he's certainly "more than just a null im happy to follow on" and I think ive explained my reasoning aplenty

 

[CakeWalker]

So we two hours away - and Doddsy has the most votes by a margin?

 

[Smart Marx]

Highest voted person gets lynched, hammer or no hammer. Majority is just the votes needed for hammer. But someone will always be lynched.

 

[Ace]

I'm back. I see were low on time so ill be brief. I didn't like Barry's original.reasoning for rugrat . On the flip side not instantly unvoting after poyser did n not voting doddsy yet does show some signs of independent thought. Which does make me feel a bit better

I'm not opposed to solving doddsy's slot either, however. Especially if it appears only a small amount of people share my suspicion of barry. I'm not voting rugrat or lethal though, I believe they are good boys.

Just doing some reading. So far, not great for doddsy. 90% of his posts are about poyser n I don't see many if ny other reads? Awkward

On to Barry's posts

Out of context I know. But at face value i like this post. Dunno if barry openly asks for vote on a team mate that doesn't have a big wagon forming. Seems unnecessary

Alright so, upon reading grims posts again, he does actually take some strong stances (juice, lethal for example). I didn't love his stuff around rugrat at the time, but the fact he didn't immediately follow poyser to doddsy (and still hasnt) again give me more confidence that these are indeed his thoughts .

unvote

vote doddsy

tl/dr version: I simply have more reasons to read barry town. Doddsy I don't really have much reason to as he's essentially been tunneling poyser fkrv2 days.

So this is the sequence of switching from having been on Barry to being happy with Doddsy. I kind of agree with most of the points Jeff makes but also something about this sequence rubs me up the wrong way. Somehow it just feels... forced.

Not planning on lynching Jeff today but he is certainly in my sights.

 

[Ace]

Vote Doddsy

 

[Comrade Khan]

So this is the sequence of switching from having been on Barry to being happy with Doddsy. I kind of agree with most of the points Jeff makes but also something about this sequence rubs me up the wrong way. Somehow it just feels... forced.

Not planning on lynching Jeff today but he is certainly in my sights.

Have I traumatized you so much

 

[Poyser]

Ok good I came back to check hoping we weren’t gonna be still stuck around with everybody on 2 votes but I see it looks like Doddsy is gonna be lynched, good stuff. I do think barry is town so I think it’s a good decision

@Rugrat why do you have barry as likely scum out of interest?

 

[Laughable Chimp]

Not sure why people have suddenly gone for Doddsy

 

[CakeWalker]

People should just switch to Lethal and remove another obvious scum player.

 

[Doddsy]

Eh, poyser are you willing to be lynched tomorrow when I flip town?

 

[CakeWalker]

@Doddsy you should just vote Lethal here.

Perhaps PoyPoy and Jeff will make the right decision and vote the most obvious scum here.

 

[Doddsy]

Realistically I won't flip town because I'm a survivor but the point stands, poyser is pretty obviously scum, became even more apparent when I went to bed and he started saying I didn't have any reasoning, despite giving stacks of reasoning yesterday