Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Ace]

Fair enough on the banter, but for future reference number mistakes like that aren’t from counting. It’s copy and pasted from the last vote count and I just needed to go back in and correct it. Anyways, play on.

I’m gonna watch some Justice League.

See you next week then

 

[Lethal]

Vote Count

Chloe B ~ 2 [Grim, Rugrat]
Jeff ~ 1 [Chloe B]
Poyser ~ 4 [Jeff, Showtime, Laughable Chimp, Banez]
Banez ~ 3 [Poyser, T’Challa, Lethal]

Nitpicking but Banez is voting Poyser, but has him as a green lean (could flip either way as he said), but does NOT vote his orange lean.

 

[Ace]

Nitpicking but Banez is voting Poyser, but has him as a green lean (could flip either way as he said), but does NOT vote his orange lean.

Yes good spot, also earlier when i interacted with him his words and actions weren't aligning re: poyser.
Bizarre play.

 

[Banez]

Hmm alright I do like that you got right onto it, but I am also cautious that you forgot your sole scum lean in the midst of that huge ass post.

Why no vote on her?

Because Poyser resolves more than 1 person in my list.

Either Poyser is town and would be correct about Magic which makes Magic orange and would also give insight on Jeff. Whereas if Poyser is scum, it would make me feel easier about Magic.

Whereas voting Juice and trying to form wagon there at this junkture would give us little to nothing to follow up for.

 

[Banez]

Imagine you guys expecting a stellar play from BELOW AVERAGE mafia player.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Nitpicking but Banez is voting Poyser, but has him as a green lean (could flip either way as he said), but does NOT vote his orange lean.

 

[Ace]

Player List:
1) Banez
2) Jeff - hider
3) Rugrat
4) Ace
5) Doddsy
6) Alco
7) Lethal
8) T'Challa
9) Odo - modkilled, VT.
10) Poyser
11) CP
12) Flay
13) Grim
14) Magic
15) Juice
16) Kajuh
17) Chimp - Miller

Here's where i'm at atm.

blue is town read or lean.

Orange is scum lean and Green are players who could flip either way.

In this case, Jeff is a hider, but he can prove that role i suppose. I dont know what to make of Poyser, seems like town Poyser with all this playing he's doing which i'm happy to see and he makes a good point about Magic which is why Magic is green.

I did find it curious how Odo said that Jeff can't be hider due to Odo's role in the game. Did Odo think we're dealing with vanilla setup with just a possible vig or was it a bluff to put pressure on Jeff?

Noteworthy thing is that Magic went on bat for Jeff after he claimed hider, if Jeff flips scum then i'd look at magic next.

Yeah i could have brought that up but it's been hot topic on last few pages so i didn't see need to mention it again. I'm not on his case coz he's pushing me. i'm on his case coz his early play seemed bit like his scum play usually does, just post here and there and avoid being center of attention while stronger players are around.

But now he doesn't mind being center of attention which is what he usually does as town so i'm unsure what to make of it.

Here, greens him and then talks about being on his case. I don't get it

 

[Lethal]

Yes good spot, also earlier when i interacted with him his words and actions weren't aligning re: poyser.
Bizarre play.

Also this:

You are correct, i haven't tried to play the game yesterday. I was here but i asked few things but thats about it. I've always found it difficult to get involved in day 1 coz of the joke posts etc.

But then again, i'm just your friendly below average mafia player (hi tweet) near you.

Feigning off difficulty of getting involved due to joke posts that seldom last past page 5 seems just parading around to appear doing something whilst doing jack shit.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Because Poyser resolves more than 1 person in my list.

Either Poyser is town and would be correct about Magic which makes Magic orange and would also give insight on Jeff. Whereas if Poyser is scum, it would make me feel easier about Magic.

Whereas voting Juice and trying to form wagon there at this junkture would give us little to nothing to follow up for.

imma be that guy. Poyser originally read juice town then switched over to null. so i disagree with your conclusion that voting juice "gives us nothing to follow up on". in fact quite a few ppl gave her a quick and easy town lread in the first few pages did they not?

 

[Lethal]

Because Poyser resolves more than 1 person in my list.

Either Poyser is town and would be correct about Magic which makes Magic orange and would also give insight on Jeff. Whereas if Poyser is scum, it would make me feel easier about Magic.

Whereas voting Juice and trying to form wagon there at this junkture would give us little to nothing to follow up for.

So you're risking losing Poyser to catch Magic and get insight on Jeff? Seems a very bold move for someone who doesn't like to engage on day 1 with all the joke posts.

She's your orange lean though. There's observable patterns in her play to resolve players around her. No buys.

 

[Lethal]

I think it's claim time bud

 

[Banez]

Claim time?

On 3 votes?

Yeah no buys.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Dont really see any reason why you couldn't be aligned and I think you are both scum independently so yes. Why, should there be a reason I can't think you are aligned?

Ok well at least the bolded makes me feel a tad better. I HATE HATE HATE scum connection posts, especially on d1, it's how i sniffed out Haza when he was "cop",

 

[Lethal]

Had a vigorous exchange with T'Challa yet no lean on him either? Interesting.

 

[Lethal]

Claim time?

On 3 votes?

Yeah no buys.

They will come